“Of course we did,” Theo says. “And don’t get your panties in a bunch. You know if the shoe was on either of our feet, you would’ve done the same thing.”
He’s not wrong about that.
“So what did you bet on? If Sutton and I were actually dating?”
“Pretty much,” Beau says, examining each of the bills. “As someone who’s been in a relationship with a person for reasons other than love or admiration, I’m uniquely qualified to see the signs of a fake relationship.”
Dammit. How did I not think about that? Beau stayed married to Shelby for a public relations stint. How did I think I was going to pull the wool over his eyes?
“I’d like the record to show that even once Beau pointed it out to us, both Theo and I chose to believe you. We both sincerely thought you were doing it for love.”
“Gee thanks,” I mutter, still mad I didn’t see the Beau plot hole a mile away. “Did anything specific give me away?”
“Nothing particular,” Beau says. “After you told us the two of you started dating, we were of course happy for you. But something felt…off.”
“Off how?” I ask. “You know, in case I ever decide to do this again.”
“Please don’t,” Theo says. “You’re really bad at it.”
“How was I bad? You believed me!”
Maddox pats me on the forearm. “At first. But then we started thinking about it. You went from ‘I’m never dating’ to full-on girlfriend in three seconds. It drew questions.”
“Liam and Finn bought it.”
“Did they?” Maddox asks. “Or were they just so happy you were even pretending to date they didn’t say shit about it and let you think they were along for the ride?”
I never thought of that. “Well, thank you for pretending to believe me. We both needed it. But rest assured now that things are very much real.”
Maddox walks over to me, wrapping me in a hug. “I’m so happy for you.”
I laugh and pat his arm. “Thanks, buddy. I’m happy too.”
The next hour is a flurry of them peppering me with questions about Sutton, how the fake relationship started, how it went, and how it ended. I have to assume this is what women do when they “spill the tea.” Because I tell them everything. The origin of the idea. The pressure I was feeling from everyone. The ass pinch at dance class and the potential bachelor auction that sent me over the edge.
I don’t go much into Sutton’s side of the deal, because a lot of that isn’t my story to tell. They know about her sister marrying Rob, and the shit show that’s gone along with that. I do tell them about how Sutton stood up for herself and dropped out of the wedding, which was maybe the best part of Saturday night.
Behind the sex. The sex was definitely number one.
But Sutton and I watching her mom’s and sister’s faces as I helped her walk out of their life? Unforgettable.
“So, now things are just…normal?”
“Pretty much,” I say. “She doesn’t have to deal with wedding planning anymore, so that frees up a lot of her time and ditched a bunch of her stress. The kids’ dance recital is Saturday, so that’s the big deal right now. Then we’re just going to enjoy the summer. Maybe take a trip. We have a while to decide, but right now, we’re just taking everything in stride.”
“That’s amazing,” Theo says, but allows a long pause before continuing. “Can I ask though, are you feeling…”
“Guilty?”
“We just want to take a temperature check,” Beau says. “Fake or not, you went from ‘I’m not ready to date’ to ‘we’re thinking about taking a vacation together’ in the blink of an eye. During hockey season. It’s just a lot, and we want to make sure you’re good.”
I start mixing the wet ingredients in the bowl as I figure out how I want to answer. “I’ve thought a lot about why I was scared to get back out there. But every reason went back to the fear that I’d stop loving Hailey. Or that I’d feel like I was cheating on her. Or that I was scared to fall for someone only for them to be taken from me again.”
“That’s a lot,” Maddox says.
“It was,” I agree. “Still is. But once I convinced myself to take the chance, the guilt evaporated. No panic. It’s like when you’re scared to get a shot and you tense up. You’ve convinced yourself it’s going to hurt like hell, only to find out it’s done and nothing bad happened.”
“Speak for yourself,” Maddox says. “Needles scare the fuck out of me.”