“But you get what I’m saying. I waited for Hailey’s spirit to start haunting me. Or something bad to happen as some sort of punishment. Or that Hailey would yell at me.”
“Your dead wife yells at you?” Maddox asks.
“Another story for another day,” I say, not wanting to admit to them that I “hear” her voice. That might be too much for them to handle today. “But what I’m saying is, that I don’t. I feel good. Happy. Sutton… She’s made me realize that I could love again. That if I had the right person’s hand to hold, the jump wouldn’t be as scary.”
Maddox’s lip curls before he’s power walking toward me, wrapping me in another hug. Shit, is he crying? “That’s the most beautiful thing I’ve ever heard.”
“Thanks?” I say, awkwardly patting his arms as he squeezes around my neck.
“We’re happy for you,” Beau says. “And we love Sutton.”
“Yes we do,” Theo says. “And you know what I think Sutton would like? Macarons!”
“Really?” I ask. “That’s your segue?”
“Smooth, wasn’t it?”
We all laugh as we go back to the baked goods we planned on making tonight.
“Come on!” Theo argues. “Asher, I know you like them. I’ve seen you eat them before.”
“I do. When they’re baked properly. Not by four athletes who took way too long to figure out what each paddle for the stand mixer did.”
“I agree with Asher,” Beau says. “Why do we need to keep trying to get these right? Why can’t we just spend our evening baking what we want, talking about Asher’s love life, and then going back to our homes to eat our baked goods while we lie about their origins?”
“Because they’re our Goliath,” Theo says. “What will it take for you guys to bake these with me?”
The three of us look at each other, trying to come up with the best use of that challenge. And when I do, I hold up my finger, because I’m about to get answers to a few burning questions I have when it comes to Theo Lawson.
“Answer one question.”
Theo’s eyebrows lift. “That’s it?”
I laugh under my breath. “I’m not talking about seeing if you’re smarter than a fifth grader. It’s time you come clean with us. And if you do, we’ll put aside our baking projects and tackle these little French fuckers with you.”
“Fine,” he says, straightening his shoulders. “Hit me.”
“If you say so,” I say. “Why did you cut your hair?”
Theo’s eyes go wide when he realizes where that question is going to lead. For a man who’s paid millions of dollars to spot an eighty miles per hour curve ball careening his way, he didn’t see this coming at all.
“As I told Sutton, who I’m assuming already told you everything that happened at the salon this week, I needed a change. It was time.”
“Yes, she told me that’s the reason you gave her for wanting a haircut,” I say, taking a seat on a stool. “She also told me about your interaction with Ellie.”
My casual drop of Ellie’s name gets audible gasps from Maddox and Beau.
“Are you serious! Sutton met Ellie?” Maddox shouts.
“Was she at the salon?” Beau asks. “How did you not tell us?”
“Because I was waiting for this,” I say, staring at Theo. I know Ellie is a touchy subject, but we need to know what’s going on with him, especially with the wedding a month away. “There Sutton was, cutting the hair of a woman named Ellie—a common name so she didn’t think much of it. Just as their appointment was wrapping up, in walks Theo. I believe the wording Sutton used was ‘I spy the tension was high.’”
“Daaaamn,” Beau says, taking a seat next to me. “So now, my question is why would there be tension? If she’s your best friend—you know, because you’ve always told us that’s all you two are—why would there be tension? Unless…”
None of us know why he’s never made a move or asked her out. From what he’s told us, they were best friends growing up. Then, like many friends we have from that part of our lives, drifted apart in college. Fate brought them back together in adulthood, with Theo getting drafted by the Nashville BlueBirds and Ellie being on their social media team.
And now he sees her every day. And he knows in a matter of weeks, she’s getting married.