“More than I thought we would. My mom’s watched them overnight a few times. She gets grandma time and the kids think it’s a party, so they don’t question it. Sutton and Maverick came over for dinner last night, but we agreed that, for now, we need to take things slow and limit the parental sleepovers until everyone is more acclimated with us being together. They say they don’t mind us going on dates, but when they saw me give her a kiss goodbye, the ‘ews’ were heard loud and clear. I don’t think any of us are ready to answer the questions of why we slept in the same bedroom.”
“Or having them walk in on you,” Maddox says with a shudder. “I’m dreading the day that happens.”
Oh shit. I didn’t even think of that one. “Thanks for reminding me to double check the locks.”
Maddox taps the tip of his nose and points at me as we all fall into the motions of working on our creations for the night. The kitchen is silent for a few minutes before we all jump at the sound of Theo smacking his hands on the prep table.
“Are none of you seriously going to try and bake macarons with me?”
The three of us look at each other, trying to figure out how to let him down gently. Finally, I bite the bullet.
“Sorry, man. I’m surprising the kids with cake pops.”
“Nice,” Maddox says as he gets out ingredients I can already tell are going to result in bear claws. The man is in his mid-twenties but craves a bear claw like a senior citizen at Bingo. “Adalyn change her favorite from the sugar cookies?”
“Nope, still loves those,” I confirm as I start arranging my ingredients. “Maverick loves cake pops. Which means, now so does Adalyn. So I thought I’d make them.”
“The kids, huh?” Beau says. “Since when are we referring to them as ‘the kids’.”
“Since they’re kids,” I say, not getting why it’s a big deal. “Maverick likes cake pops. Adalyn likes anything sweet. She tried one this week and loves them now too. I thought it would be nice to have when they came over tomorrow night for dinner. That’s it.”
“Two dinners in a few nights?” Maddox asks. “Didn’t you just say you two were taking things slow?”
“We are,” I defend.
“I’m just saying that two dinner dates in the same week, with the whole family, is a big step. And Maverick has slept over there? For most people, those would be very big steps.”
“Maybe. But it’s easier this way. Neither of us need to worry about childcare if they just come over. Sure, us going out on dates at the beginning helped with the situation. Made things much easier. But now that we don’t have to, dinner at the house is just easier.”
No one replies to me, which is strange considering who I’m in the room with. So when I look up, I’m taken aback to see three pairs of eyes staring at me, all with an equally confused look.
“What?”
“What do you mean, ‘situation’?” Theo asks with air quotes.
“Huh?”
“You said situation,” Beau says. “Why did you use that word?”
And this is why I don’t talk. Because when I talk, I say things I shouldn’t.
“Situation that we’re single parents,” I stammer out, trying to keep busy mixing my ingredients, while also knowing that’s probably a dead giveaway that I’m lying out of my ass.
“Because you two were hiding it?” Maddox asks, stepping close to examine me. “I didn’t think you were being secretive?”
“We weren’t. It was just easier.”
“Easier for what?” Beau prods. “Unless there was something else going on with you and Sutton at the beginning of your relationship that you want to tell us?”
“Something you kept from us?” Theo adds. “For…reasons.”
I narrow my eyes at them, because I know what they’re up to. Assholes. “Which one of you guessed it?”
Beau steps up, brushing invisible lint from his shirt, wearing a very smug look. “If by guessing ‘it’, you mean figured out that you and Sutton were only dating for pretenses and it didn’t start as a real relationship but turned into one? That would be me. Now pay up, fuckers.”
Theo and Maddox let out heavy groans as they fish their wallets out of their pockets and each hand Beau a hundred-dollar bill.
“You guys fucking bet on me?”