Ensley and I both spun around and saw the very person we’d been talking about approaching. She wore a smile I didn’t trust, and every part of me wanted to turn and walk away from her.
“Berkeley…how are you doing?” Ensley asked.
Walking straight over to me, she reached up and went to kiss me on the lips. I quickly stepped back, causing her to stumble forward. I caught her by the arms and helped her balance herself before moving back again.
“What was that about?” I asked, frowning at her.
Her cheeks turned pink. “I was coming to say hello.”
“By kissing me on the mouth?”
Berkeley glanced between all three of us before focusing back on me. “I mean, it’s not like we haven’t kissed plenty of times.” When no one said anything, she let out an awkward laugh. “Why are you so upset? I mean…we do have our history, Gatlin.”
I was pretty sure I heard a growl come from Ensley, before she said, “This is my cue to leave.” Turning on her heel, my sister made her way over to my mother and grandmother.
Caden cleared his throat and said, “I need to get to cleaning up.”
“I’ll join you in a second,” I said to Caden, as he nodded, tipped his hat at Berkeley, and practically ran away.
Facing Berkeley, I started to say something, but she spoke first.
“I was hoping to catch you before the dancing began.” She tried to put her hand on my chest, but I caught it. “You’re going to save the first dance for me, right?”
Gently moving her arm back to her side, I shook my head. “What are you doing, Berkeley?”
“What do you mean?”
I sighed and rubbed at the back of my neck. “I told you, it’s over between us.”
She puckered her lip into a fake pout. “Gatlin, you know she can’t satisfy you like I can.”
Not rising to the bait, I asked, “Who?”
“The country pumpkin. I get it, she’s new, and you probably like the chase. But she can’t do the things to you in bed that I can.”
I sighed. “It’s bumpkin, not pumpkin, and Emberlynn is a friend. Will that change? I don’t know, maybe. For right now, she’s a friend whom I’d like to get to know better.”
Her brows dropped as her hands moved to her hips. “What does she have that I don’t?”
“This isn’t about comparing the two of you, Berkeley. When we started our arrangement, I made it perfectly clear that I wasn’t interested in anything other than a sexual relationship, and you agreed.”
“That was before I fell in love with you.”
My eyes widened as I took another step away from her. I slowly shook my head as I tried to find a way not to hurt her feelings.
“Berkeley, I’m so sorry if I led you on. I really thought we were on the same page, and you assured me that we were. But when I saw you hinting at more, I ended things, hoping you wouldn’t get hurt. It seems that I failed.”
Tears built in her eyes, and I felt like a complete ass. “Do you not have any feelings for me at all?”
God, I really hated having to hurt her further. I drew in a slow breath and let it out. “I’m sorry. I don’t feel anything for you other than friendship.”
“And with the vet?”
I looked over toward where Emberlynn stood with Luke and the goats. Emberlynn was crouched down, petting one of them, a wide smile on her face. My chest warmed…and I knew my brother Caden was right. I was falling for her.
Focusing my attention back on Berkeley, I ignored her question and simply said, “I’m sorry, Berkeley.”
She let out a harsh laugh. “You’re actually falling for her?”