I did the only thing I knew to do. Be truthful with her and myself. “I am.”
Closing her eyes, she said, “I…I just thought…” Opening them once again, she went on. “I just thought that you’d eventually fall in love with me too. What’s wrong with me?”
“Nothing’s wrong with you, Berkeley. You’re a beautiful woman. I like having you as a friend, but no matter how hard I try, I don’t see a future with us together like that. I never meant to make you think that I did.”
She wiped a tear away. “No, you never made any promises to me.” She shrugged one shoulder. “I guess I was holding out hope you’d want more than what we shared.”
I wasn’t sure she’d tell me the truth, but I had to ask her about Thursday night.
“What did you tell Emberlynn in the bathroom?” I asked.
Her cheeks turned pink, and she dropped her head. “I always hated those girls in high school. The ones who made other girls feel like less than. I always thought I was a girls' girl, until the day I saw you sitting with Emberlynn in Anna’s. The way you looked at her…I knew you liked her. Something in me flipped, and…and I got so jealous.”
When she looked up at me, I was about to tell her again that Emberlynn and I were only friends. She must have read my mind.
“You may not have known at the time that you were attracted to her. But I knew. So in Granby, I confronted her in the bathroom and told her that we were together. She didn’t believe me, and when she went to leave, I told her that she could never make you happy in bed the way I did, and I…I said something really crude.”
I closed my eyes and cursed under my breath. “What did you say?”
I wasn’t even sure I wanted to know, but I needed to know.
She swallowed hard. “I told her that if she rode your face that night, you’d be comparing her to me the whole time.”
My eyes flew open wide. “We never even did that, Berkeley! Why in the hell would you say something like that?”
“I’m sorry, Gatlin! I was so jealous, seeing you out with her! You always kept us hidden, like I was some dirty little secret.”
“We weren’t dating, Berkeley.”
She held up her hands. “I know! It was just about sex, and I agreed to it. That doesn’t mean it still doesn’t hurt to see you look at her the way I prayed you’d look at me one day.”
I sighed, suddenly feeling tired. “I didn’t mean to hurt you.”
She barked a sharp, gruff laugh. “And I didn’t mean to fall in love with you, but both things happened.” She blew out a breath and looked around awkwardly. Looking at me again, she said, “If you want, I can tell her I made it all up.”
“No,” I said, with a quick shake of my head. “I’ll take care of it.”
Taking a step closer, she wore a wobbly smile. “May I hug you?”
My eyes darted past her to see Emberlynn watching us. She quickly looked away.
Meeting her gaze, I shook my head. “I think it’s for the best if we just go our separate ways.”
Her vulnerable smile vanished, before a wide, fake grin replaced it. “Can’t blame a girl for trying.”
“Goodbye, Berkeley.”
“See you around, Gatlin.”
Berkeley lifted her chin, squared her shoulders, and walked away.
My eyes went back to Emberlynn. Luke was still standing next to her, and now my father, Emeline, and Katie, Emeline’s adopted daughter, was with them as well.
Now wasn’t the time to go talk to her, so I turned and headed into the barn to help Caden clean up. I just needed to wait for my dance. One dance, and then I could tell her the truth about everything.
Emberlynn
I tried my best to keep up with the conversation around me, but my eyes kept drifting back toward where Gatlin was talking to Berkeley. I wanted to kick myself the moment I’d made that stupid comment about her. That wasn’t who I was. Plus, I didn’t for one second believe they were together. Gatlin would have never lied about that.