“Hey, Cherry Pie. Does everyone know about my nickname?” I give him a hearty squeeze around the middle.
“Everyone,” he confirms with a smirk. “I heard the kitchen crew rib him over it just the other day. They caught on to Nina teasing him about it. It’s been worth it coming to work just to listen to him stutter through those conversations.”
Jude gives me a gleeful look and hops up to sit on the desk. “Told you we came to the right place.”
She pats a spot next to her and I jump up so that we’re both facing Theo. He looks between us, and it seems he’s slowly coming to understand what he’s in for. He leans back onto the wall and crosses his arms tight over his chest, shaking his head at Jude who stifles a laugh.
I whistle. “Lay off the weights, Jordan. You’re about to Hulk right out of that shirt.”
He rolls his eyes, but there’s no hiding the way the tips of his ears turn pink. “If you think flattery’s going to get a word out of me—”
Jude tisks. “He’s right. We need to do better than that if we’re going to get him to talk.”
“There won’t be any talking. He’s my friend.”
“So am I…” Jude smiles sweetly.
“And me,” I add, batting my lashes. “You wouldn’t disappoint us like that, would you, Theo?”
I wind my arms around Jude and we pout up at him like a pair of sad puppies begging for a treat.
Theo blinks. “I love you both but that act is so bad, it’s embarrassing.”
“Oh, come on!” I throw my head back. “Help me out, here. You have no idea what kind of mindfuck the last few weeks have been. He says he’s not interested in relationships one second, and the next he’s cuddling me in a bakery.”
“After running to rescue her,” Jude adds, with an earnest raise of her brows.
“Go to him,” Theo says, unmoved. “I don’t see what good it’ll do to talk to me about this.”
“Theo,” Jude says lightly. “You know that thing we did in the backseat of your car a couple months ago? If you tell us—”
“He talks about you constantly,” Theo blurts, staring at Jude all wide-eyed. “I heard the servers comparing notes the other day. They know his reputation and it sounds like he hasn’t taken any of them out. I’m talking since the restaurant opened. It used to be his thing, dating the serving staff. If you can even call it dating.”
My chest goes all warm and tight. He talks about me constantly. Constantly.
I turn to Jude who grins at me wide as a Cheshire cat. “You little minx. I’m going to need a detailed description of that thing you did in the backseat. A full play-by-play with drawn diagrams should suffice.”
She laughs. “To use on Finn?”
I sigh dramatically. “That would require him to sleep with me.”
“You aren’t sleeping together?” Theo frowns. “That’s new.”
I chuckle. “New for me or new for him?”
“Both of you, I guess.” He stares at me a while, chewing on the inside of his cheek.
“Spill, Theo,” Jude says suddenly, jabbing an accusing finger in his direction. “You’re doing the cheek thing! What are you hiding from us?”
Theo gives a defeated groan, resting his head back against the wall. “I’m not hiding anything. Look, I feel like an ass even saying this out loud and I’d much rather you get this out of him directly… Do you know anything about what happened with his mom?”
I nod and watch him exchange a meaningful look with Jude. “What? What’s that look about?”
“I’m surprised, that’s all. He doesn’t talk about her. Ever,” Theo explains. “I’m sure you noticed this act he likes to pull?”
“Which act?”
“Theo calls him a happy leprechaun. How he’s chipper ninety-nine percent of the time.”