“That’s not an act, though.”
“You’re right. It isn’t,” Theo concedes. “He genuinely is that happy, for the most part. But then there’s the one percent. Has he told you about his dad, at all?”
“I know there’s something wrong there, but he never gave me specifics.” They eye each other again. I turn to Jude. “Do you know about it?”
She winces apologetically. “We met him for drinks after a visit with his dad one day. It kind of spilled out.”
My stomach sinks. “I feel like an idiot.”
“Don’t take it personally,” Theo says kindly. “If there’s one thing he talks about less than his mom, it’s this.”
I stare down at my wedge heels, letting them dangle from my toes. “Honestly, it’s not even that he hasn’t told me—that’s his choice to make. I’m annoyed I let myself make more of this than it really is. Built it up in my head into something it’s not.” I turn to Jude. “Where have you been? You’re supposed to be my Jiminy Cricket in all this!”
“I don’t think you’re making more of it than it is. Finn doesn’t just go around cuddling women and dealing out forehead kisses.”
“Yeah?” Theo pipes in. “He kisses you on the forehead?”
I groan. “Enough about the forehead kisses. I may as well be his kid sister!”
“He also gave you a nickname.”
“Yes, Jujube, that simply must mean he’s in love with me.”
She raises her brows. “He took one look at you naked and locked himself in his room to jerk off—”
Theo chokes on a breath, looking suddenly distraught. “Fucking hell, Jude—”
“And then he dragged you into his room to watch you—”
“I don’t need to hear any of this!” Theo cuts in loudly, glaring at the ceiling like it just started hurling insults at him. “Look, Jenna. I’d tell you about his dad if you asked because you’re a sister to Jude. But I think it’s worth waiting to hear it from him. If he’s already talking about his mom, I doubt this is too far behind. He must be into you.”
I stare at Theo, considering. If one of Finn’s closest friends seems to think he’s into me… I shake my head abruptly. This is Finn we’re talking about. Certified commitment-phobe. Accredited perma-bachelor. Licensed for emotional detachment.
“Oh, what do you know?” I grumble at Theo, only half-kidding. To Jude I add: “He’s seen a lot of people naked.”
“So have you,” she counters without missing a beat. “And still, you have feelings for him. And you’d date him if he wanted to.”
I flush. Consider denying it. Theo gives me a single brow raise and a half shrug that says, well?
These last few weeks… the forehead kisses, the way he beelines for my favorite bakery every time Ronnie calls since he did it the first time. It only confirmed my suspicions: that Finn Palmer would be someone I’d give up my own commitment-free existence for. He makes me feel like I’m more than a body made for a man’s attention. That I’m good enough for the sweet parts, too.
I let my next breath balloon my cheeks before blowing it all the way out. “How do I pull this off? How do I get someone with no interest in relationships to decide he wants to be with me like that?”
Only a proper lady would attract a good man—
“Patience,” Theo says, cutting off Ronnie’s voice. “Just being there for them. Accepting that maybe all it’ll ever be is friendship, and that it’s good enough in its own right.”
I wrinkle my nose at him. “Who invited Gandhi over here?”
Jude gives a closed-mouthed laugh, but the hearts in her eyes could serve as target practice for a cherub.
“Yeah, let’s all laugh at me,” Theo says, pushing his fingers through the abundance of curls on top of his head. “It’s not like I got a woman who hated my guts to change her mind about me or anything. Just ignore me. I’ll keep sitting here, pining away.”
“Pine quietly, won’t you?” I stick out my tongue at him. “Besides, this is me we’re talking about. We’re going to need to think big. Like… Nineties teen romcom makeovers kind of big. Maybe I’ll dye my hair back to my natural color.”
Jude stares thoughtfully at the wall. “You could try to make him jealous? Oh—you could get a fake boyfriend!”
I wave away the suggestion. “That never works. They always end up staying in their fake relationship.”