Page List

Font Size:

“A match made in heaven,” he says happily before returning to his position beside Cassie.

Shaye pretends to consider stealing the photo of Ben before picking a new gift from the pile. She opens the largest present, which turns out to be a veggie chopper that looks to be at least ten years old, but is still brand new in its As Seen on TV packaging. “I could use this!”

Cassie’s parents are next, and they both take turns reading ho ho ho jokes, jockeying for position.

Carmen manages to get through her index card with a mostly straight face. “If I’m on your naughty list, don’t ho-ho-hold it against me…I’m a bad elf.”

Dante mutters something about her definitely being a bad elf as he accepts that everyone voted her to move up in the order. He reaches for the recipe card box and selects one that reads, “What kind of vacation does Santa like?” He glances around the room before delivering the punch line. “An all-inclusive ho-ho-holiday.”

All he gets in response is groans.

He waves us down. “I’ll read another one. Oh, okay, yes this one. I’m sorry to my daughters.” He laughs under his breath. “Which elf is Santa’s favourite? The ho-ho-horny one.”

All three girls give their dad a thumbs down, but everyone else gives a thumbs up, and Carmen accepts that she needs to pick next. She steals Ben’s photo from Jules, who in turn steals the work socks and booze from Campbell, who picks a new present from the table.

It’s a puzzle of a lighthouse, and there’s an apology note taped to the cover of the box explaining that three pieces are missing.

Everyone agrees it’s a very good present, and Dante, who picks next, steals it from Campbell.

“I’m starting to think you all like to watch me unwrap presents,” he says.

Cassie laughs like that’s the funniest thing she’s ever heard.

And for the first time tonight, Shaye looks annoyed with my wife.

It’s not like I want to defend Cassie’s interest in the annoyingly handsome brewery owner, but Shaye has done nothing but irritate him since she arrived in Pine Harbour. If Campbell is nicer to anyone else than her, she’s brought that on herself.

Not that I’d ever say that to her. Relationship advice between us only flows one way. Shaye would never ask me, and I’d never offer it.

I’m in no place to pontificate about relationship success points, anyway.

Also, I’ve lost track of the gift exchange while ruminating. I don’t know what Campbell opened, or Garrett, who picked next. Now Theo is reading cards, to try to bump me out of my second-last picking order.

And he gets a round of thumbs up, so…

I stand and circle the table. There are only three gifts left. I consider just stealing the photo of Ben from Carmen, but then I recognize the red wrapping paper on one of the gifts.

It’s paper that we had at our house. Cassie bought a megaroll of it three years ago, and she wrapped my presents in it two years in a row.

I pick it up and present it to the room. It’s a cylinder, heavier than I expect for the size of it, and it’s got a bit of soft give as I squeeze it in my hand. When I peel back the paper, I understand why it felt almost squishy, but heavy. It’s a crocheted washcloth, a flat ladybug, wrapped around a bottle of homemade hot sauce. Both of them are past Cassie experiments, prototypes of something she thought she could sell online and then gave up on because I wasn’t supportive enough.

“I needed both of these things,” I say gruffly, not looking at her. “They’re perfect.”

“What are they?” Theo asks.

“Mine,” I say as neutrally as I can manage.

He takes the hint and doesn’t try to steal them. He goes for another of the remaining gifts, and then it’s Cassie’s turn. She makes everyone show her what they have, one by one. When she gets to me, she pauses for a second, and I wonder if she might just take her own gifts back to deprive me of having them.

But then she moves on, snagging the work socks from her sister, who steals a bottle of maple syrup from Campbell, who steals the socks from Cassie, leaving her empty handed again.

With a laugh, she takes the final gift on the pile, opening it up, ending the game.

“Merry Christmas, everyone!” Jules waves her bottle of maple syrup in the air. “Now we can⁠—”

“No, wait. We have to keep reading the puns,” her mother says, interrupting her. “Some very good ones are still in there.”

“So we didn’t read your best work yet, hmm?” Rory snatches the recipe box. “What is Santa’s best day on the golf course? When he scores a ho-ho-hole in one. Mom, if that was you, that’s a groaner.”


Novels you may like ...