Page List

Font Size:

I nod. Good one, I mouth.

Grabbing another index card, I lean into the slutty, for Cassie’s sake.

Santa’s tombstone will read “Big belly, bigger laugh, biggest ho ho ho in the North Pole”.

And when I deposit it with the others, Cassie is still watching me. I feel naked, even though nobody will know that I wrote that, and I’m sure it’s tame compared to some of the other cards. Most of them.

I’m trying, Cass.

When Jules’s timer goes off, everyone moves into the living room. Jules delights in getting an extra-small chair for Ben to sit on, in preparation for picking first. The White Elephant gifts are piled on the coffee table, and all together, they look exactly as shabby as Cassie wanted.

Zero good wrapping jobs.

A lot of excess tape.

One person used masking tape instead of Scotch tape.

Mine, wrapped in newsprint and red twine, doesn’t look as garish as some others, but that tracks for me. It feels like a metaphor. I’ve never managed to be exactly what Cassie wanted, never as wild and free as she hoped, but I still try, even if I end up doing something that’s bland and pedestrian.

Cassie is sitting in an armchair, and Campbell and Theo have dragged in stools to sit on either side of her like sentinels.

Jules and Shaye are on the loveseat, Rory and Garrett are sitting in the picture window, which leaves me to slide in next to Carmen and Dante on the long couch.

“How does this work if I want to make you pick before me?” Ben asks Jules.

She thrusts the recipe card box at him. “Do your worst.”

He flips the lid open and takes out a card. Reads it. Grins. Groans. And then says, “Santa has a new dating app bio. Looking for a ho ho ho... just kidding, I’m ready to settle down.”

“Thumbs down.” Jules glares around the room. “Who wrote that? That’s slut-shaming. Santa should be so lucky as to land a ho ho ho.”

That makes Rory snicker, and Garrett puts his thumb up. “This is for Jules, to be clear.”

Ben shakes his head. “Okay, okay. I’m clear on the rules now. I want another shot.”

She waves her hand. “Go ahead. Do better.”

He flips through a few cards, then waves one in the air. “This is good. Santa and Mrs. Claus have written a self-help guide for married couples titled Ho Ho Horny: A Life of Giving and Receiving.”

That gets an immediate round of thumbs up.

He waves Jules to the tiny chair and takes her seat next to Shaye.

Cassie’s sister considers the recipe box, but ends up circling the pile of gifts instead, finally selecting the one that’s covered in masking tape. She holds it aloft like a trophy, then makes a big production of unwrapping it. Inside is an older model iPad box, the kind some people keep because they’re sure they’ll have a use for it someday. And inside that…

She groans as she pulls out a very nice gilt picture frame, with a very proud high school football photo of Ben.

“Don’t worry, Jules,” he says as he stands up. “There are eight people after me. Maybe one of them will steal that from you.”

“I’m not holding my breath.”

“I want to see you put that on your bedside table tonight before I leave.”

“Pick your poison,” she snaps, stealing the spot he’s just vacated.

He examines the table before picking up the snow globe I brought. Like Jules, he takes his time unwrapping it, making a production, and when he opens it, it’s to oohs and ahhs.

Campbell is next, and he reaches for the recipe box first. But after reading, The best part of North Pole training is ho-ho-homework... said no elf ever, and getting a round of thumbs down, he declares that he’s not a stand-up comedian and grabs a present from the pile. Inside is a thick pair of work socks, and inside those are tiny bottles of booze.


Novels you may like ...