Page 78 of What Did They Fear?

Page List

Font Size:

“What?” Whit asked.

I blinked at him, but my mind was entirely on Tyson.

Celeste’s boyfriend.

If Celeste’s death had been staged to cover up Tegan’s murder, then it was highly unlikely that Tyson was her killer. He’d had nothing to do with it.

I’d been so sure. I’d gone through it a thousand times. The timeline. The way he’d let her walk down to the beach alone at midnight while he had gone to bed to sleep off the alcohol. No man let a woman do that—not a man who’d supposedly been in love.

Every single night since he’d been released after the police had questioned him about Celeste’s murder, I’d convinced myself the cops had gotten it wrong.

I ran through the details again. A killer on the dune, burying a dead girl in the sand. Celeste coming down over the rise and seeing him do it.

And Tyson, nineteen years old, was too drunk to walk her to her favorite spot on the beach.

No version of that night had him as the man holding the shovel. There never had been. I’d just stopped looking for anybody else.

The realization didn’t just hit me, it leveled me.

“Hey.” Whit reached across the counter and pressed his hand over mine. “What’s wrong?”

“All this time I’ve been convinced Tyson killed her,” I choked out. “I accused him of her murder. I said things publicly—to the media, to my family, and to his parents. I branded him as a monster.”

Whit’s hand tightened over mine. His expression shifted as a raw pain flickered behind his eyes.

“Shit. Shit. I blamed him.”

“Angel, look at me,” he said, his voice thick with feeling. “I know what it’s like to have people I know look at me and see a monster. I know what it’s like to have the finger pointed at me when I was drowning in grief. It nearly destroyed me.”

“Oh, God. That’s right. You were blamed for Charlotte’s disappearance.” I clenched my fists, digging my nails into my palms until they hurt. “Fucking hell, I’m just as bad as those asshole reporters who ruined your life.”

“No. You’re not. You were grieving and angry. Those reporters were cold and ruthless. You were a grief-stricken sister looking for answers.”

“But I ruined Tyson’s life, Whit.” Guilt poisoned my veins. “I’m supposed to be the Avenging Angel. I built that podcast on finding the truth and getting justice for the forgotten.”

Whit stood, walked around the kitchen island, and sat on the stool next to mine. He reached over and drew me into him, wrapping his arms around my shoulders and pulling me against his chest.

“I destroyed an innocent man because of my own stubborn certainty.” I forced down my emotions. “I’ve spent a decade hating him, channeling all my grief and fury into a man who had always claimed to be just as broken by Celeste’s death as I was.

“Oh my god.” I gasped, my vision blurring as the room spun. “What did I do? Whit ... what did I do to him?”

My chest caved, squeezing the air from my lungs. The entire foundation of my life since Celeste had been murdered splintered into a million agonizing pieces.

“Hey, come on.” He rubbed his hand over my hair and cradled the back of my neck.

I had never let a man hold me like this before. I had always been the strong one, the shield, the weapon. But in Whit’s embrace, I felt safe enough to let go completely.

I covered my face with my hands, and my body shook as the suffocating weight of both grief and guilt crashed down on me at once.

Whit shifted his position to hold me tightly against his broad chest.

I didn’t pull away. I buried my face in the crook of his neck. He was so steady, so solid. He didn’t make the moment about him, and he certainly could have. He had been on the receiving end of a horrendously wrong accusation. He knew the damage it caused.

Yet, he just held me while I fell apart.

I sucked back my tears and forced down the suffocating guilt in my chest. The shame didn’t vanish, but it crystallized into a fierce, burning resolve.

I pulled back and wiped my face with the back of my hand.


Novels you may like ...