I met Whit’s gaze. “I owe Tyson an apology,” I said, my voice steadying. “A public one. Plus, I owe Tegan a voice—and her mother.”
Whit’s brow furrowed, his posture stiffening. “What do you mean a public one?”
“I need to do another podcast.” I stood up. “I’m going to reveal everything. Tegan’s body, the staged crime scene, how wrong I was about Tyson, the police incompetence. All of it.”
“No.” Whit’s tone was full of fire. “Absolutely not, Angel. It’s too dangerous.”
“Whit, I have to tell the truth, I can’t—”
“The truth is that someone tried to kill you. Twice!” He stepped closer, but I backed away. “That podcast is why we’ve been hiding you.” His eyes were wide with terror or anger. Maybe both. “The killer may not know that we’ve found Tegan’s body yet. That buys us time to investigate her disappearance again.”
“They should’ve investigated that properly when they found Celeste.”
“I agree. But airing that podcast now tells the killer her body was found. If you suggest that Celeste’s death was staged to cover up another murder, then the crosshairs you already have on your back will become a massive glowing target. I can’t let you do it.”
He was arguing hard, his chest heaving, terrified for my life.
And he was entirely correct. I knew the risks.
But I didn’t care.
“I can’t stay silent, Whit,” I said, meeting his gaze. “Even if I stay quiet, someone still wants me dead. My only weapon is my voice. I have eight hundred thousand listeners, so if I go public, it might actually protect me. The spotlight is my only shield.”
“The spotlight only protects you from someone who is rational and cunning. This man attacked you in a hospital for fuck’s sake. He’s not deterred by attention; he’s provoked by it. You’re playing Russian roulette with a murderer, Angel.” Whit’s voice dropped to cold and clinical, and somehow, that was worse than shouting. “You’re being reckless.”
“It’s not recklessness. It’s who I am,” I snapped back. “My podcast is about honesty. It’s about giving victims a voice. I spent eleven years being wrong, and that helped a murderer stay in the shadows while an innocent man paid the price. I am not going to hide that truth because I was wrong. Everyone needs to know, for Tegan’s sake.”
“Tegan or Celeste?”
“Both.”
Whit stared at me, completely still, his hands curling into fists at his sides. The silence stretched between us, thick, heavy, and entirely unresolved.
He wouldn’t back down, not when my safety was at risk.
And there was no way I was backing down. I had to correct what I had done wrong.
The air in the room practically vibrated with tension, and it cut deeply to know that I was the one putting that look of sheer, helpless dread in his eyes.
I was about to light a fuse on a killer’s decade-old secret.
It scared the hell out of me, but I had to do it.
SIXTEEN
ANGEL
Icalled Michelle Dawson first thing this morning, after I’d downed two coffees to settle my nerves. It was the hardest phone call of my life. The police had already told her about Tegan’s body being found, but it was my job to remind her that Tegan hadn’t run away, hadn’t started some new life somewhere far from home the way the police had always let her believe.
It broke her heart that her daughter had been lying in the sand this whole time. I didn’t give her any of my theories, she didn’t need them. She needed the truth, and a promise, and I gave her both. I would not stop until whoever did this was caught.
I spent the rest of the day building the podcast episode. I kept it tight. Facts only. Nothing in the script I couldn’t prove, exactly as I’d promised Whit. But I kept getting choked up, sometimes so badly I could hardly breathe, and I had to delete and record again and again.
The episode wasn’t ready. Not even close. So I did a quick teaser instead, explaining that my sister’s murder was now connected to another cold case, and that I’d share all the detailed and shocking facts very soon. I wanted more nailed down before I aired this podcast.
By the time I heard the garage door’s low rumble, I was exhausted, hungry, and staring blankly at the screen.
Whit walked into the kitchen, keys jingling in his hand. He didn’t even take off his jacket before he asked, “Did you release the podcast?”