I have always wanted to live somewhere else—before, it was just to experience more than I have in Holbrook, but for the past year, it has been because “home” is a dreadful place to be. I’m not sure Boston is where I would have ended up, but I’m not opposed to it.
The main thing that bothers me isn’t even living with Tor when we’ve only just started dating. It’s knowing how behind I would be. It has made me feel like a complete failure to watch the people I graduated with start the next chapter of their lives, knowing that should have been me, but I completely blew it. Even if I try my best to catch up now, the best I can do is start everything a year late.
And if I were doing it on my own, maybe that wouldn’t be as noticeable, but doing it alongside Tor would highlight my failure over and over again for the next four years. When he’s graduating, I’ll still have a year left. Not only could that potentially complicate our future plans if we are still together, but it’s just… not fair.
I can’t get my lost year back, no matter what I do now, no matter how hard I try to catch up. It’s just too late.
Thinking about Boston may not have been the best thing because by the time I get to my apartment, it’s brought me all the way back down.
Tor notices as soon as I step inside the door. He asked me while I was working if I’d be hungry when I got home, but, of course, I didn’t answer him since I was avoiding my phone. Now I smell something incredible cooking, and my heart sinks because I already ate between customers.
“Hey,” Tor says as I enter the living room.
“Hey. I didn’t know you were cooking.”
He shrugs. “You didn’t answer, so I figured I’d play it safe. If you’re not hungry, you’ll have leftovers.”
I’m not very hungry, but I will eat some of it. I’ll feel too guilty if I don’t.
“You okay?” Tor asks, noticing something is off.
I nod, attempting a smile. “How are you? How was your family stuff?”
“About as expected.” His mouth tugs up slightly, but it obviously wasn’t a fun day, and now I feel bad about that, too.
“Hey, since I have my own place now, do you think I could get my journal back?”
Tor glances up, watching me for a moment. “Why?”
His question surprises me, so it takes a second to find an answer. “Uh… I don’t know. It feels weird that someone I don’t even know still has it, and now that things are different, I’d like to have an outlet for those times I need to work on my mental health.”
“Why don’t we get you a new journal?” he suggests.
My eyebrows rise. “I can’t have the other one back?”
“You can, but I’d prefer you didn’t read it anymore. After this weekend, I’d love it if you never thought about my brother again.”
His words make my heart sink, mostly because it never occurred to me that he might feel the way Russell did about all this. I view Tor as such a step up from Russell in that department, considering it now is disappointing.
“Does it bother you that your brother… I mean, of course it bothers you that he—” I stop, trying to think how to even word this. I despise using similar wording to what Russell’s disgusting friends used that night I overheard them talking, but it’s the only thing I can think of. “Is this a possessive thing? Does it bother you that he was… inside me first even though it wasn’t my choice?”
“No,” he says firmly enough that I believe him, but then he meets my gaze and says something far worse. “But I know you were attracted to him, and now that he’s gone… I’d like for Tim to stay completely out of your mind.”
I can’t breathe for a moment. I feel like he just gut-punched me.
That was the narrative the lawyer spun to defend Tim. That I liked him, and I was angry when Tim “rejected me” after that night, so I’d made up this awful story about what happened…
“I can’t believe you just said that.”
He studies me for a moment, as if assessing damage he hadn’t intended. “I didn’t mean… I wasn’t saying you wanted it or justifying anything that happened to you, Cassie. I wasn’t judging you. I’m just not interested in sharing you, even with a memory, so I’d rather we put him behind us than nurture anything that may not have been resolved.”
“I wasn’t—I’m not attracted to your brother. I shot him,” I say, wide-eyed.
“I know. I was there,” Tor says, almost lightly.
I am not amused.
I am flabbergasted.