"How long does one of these take you?" she said.
"Twenty-five minutes. Half an hour if I'm talking too much."
"They're extraordinary."
"They're demonstrations," Pell said, and the word came out with a corner on it. "They're a magic trick. You do it fast enough and in front of enough people and everybody in the room thinks they've seen something." He took the board out of her hands — not roughly, but he took it — and put it back in the drawer and closed the drawer with his hip. "Nobody's ever bought one. I've offered."
"Mr. Pell—"
"Do you know what the difference is between Reid Calloway and me?" He said it to the window. "Twelve years and a story. He had a story — the sign painter, the dropping out, the shop with no heat. Dana had a story, the best one going, the woman who quit and came back at thirty-six. I have taught in this room for nineteen years and my story is that I have taught in this room for nineteen years, and there is no gallery in this state that has ever been able to do anything with that."
"You sound angry."
"I sound accurate." He turned around. "I'm not going to sit here four days after somebody killed two people I cared about and pretend I think the art world is a meritocracy. There are four hundred painters on this lake and the ones who rise are the ones who can stand up in a room and be a person about it. That's not a conspiracy. It's just not talent." He stopped, and passed a hand back over his head, and when he spoke again his voice had come down. "Dana got very good. In the end. She earned it in the ugliest, slowest way I've ever watched anybody earn anything and she was better in April than she was in 2013 by a distance I can't measure. That's true and I'll say it under oath. It was also true that she was not the best painter in this room in 2012, and the woman who was is doing signage in Cloquet."
Isla let a silence go, and let it get uncomfortable, and then she said, "Where were you Monday night?"
He didn't blink. "Here till nine, there's an open studio on Mondays. Then home. I've got the upstairs of a house on Jefferson."
"Anybody with you?"
"No. My wife died in 2018."
"I'm sorry. Tuesday night?"
"Class till eight." A beat. "Then home."
"Straight home?"
"Straight home."
James, who had said almost nothing for twenty minutes and who did this better than anybody Isla had ever worked with, looked up from his notebook with an expression of mild administrative boredom.
"That's the green Outback in the lot?" he said. "The one with the roof rack?"
"That's mine."
"Great. Just for the file — anybody see you come in Tuesday? Neighbor, porch light, anything?"
"I doubt it."
"Sure."
They talked about the roster after that. Twelve-week terms, three a year, nineteen years — Pell said he had the sign-in sheets going back to 2009 in the flat files and Isla asked for all of them and he agreed immediately, and he agreed to a formal statement, and he agreed to a DNA elimination sample without so much as a pause, and he walked them back down through the colored light of the stairwell with his hands behind his back.
At the door, with the rain coming in under the overhang, he said:
"You should look at the ones who quit."
Isla stopped. "Say more."
"Most people can't finish." Pell was looking past her at the street. "That's the tragedy of the whole business and nobody outside it understands it. It isn't talent that runs out, it's the last twenty percent. I have watched hundreds of people in that room make something genuinely good and then stand in front of it for six weeks and be unable to close it, and every one of them stops coming eventually, and every one of them is still out there in this town somewhere with the canvas in a garage." He put his half-glasses back on. "If you're looking for somebody angry about painting, that's your list. It's a long one and I made most of it."
"Thank you," Isla said.
She got about four steps down before she turned around.
"Mr. Pell. Tuesday night — the coffee at the diner up in Two Harbors. You mentioned that upstairs, when you were telling me about the shore drive you take when you can't sleep."