Isla stood in the middle of the room with the farm report still playing on the paint-crusted stool because nobody had turned the radio off and nobody was going to until Iverson released the room, and she felt what she had been holding at arm's length since three-nineteen in the morning close the distance and settle.
Somebody had brought their own brushes.
Somebody had brought their own brushes into this building through a door that needed a fob, at midnight, in November, and had killed a woman with one blow from behind while she was working and had then stood at the working distance and finished her painting for her and had taken their brushes home.
She took forty-one photographs. She took them at the raking angle and straight on and close, and she got the whole surface in overlapping sections, and then she went and found Theo Lindgren.
He was on three with his door open and the lights off and his coat on over the same clay-crusted work shirt, sitting on a stool in a room full of shelves of unfired greenware, pale gray shapes standing in rows in the dimness like a congregation. He had not been home. There was a Duluth PD blanket folded on the workbench beside him, squared at the corners, which somebody had done for him or which he had done himself in the last hour to give his hands something to do.
He stood up when he saw her.
"I can't go in there," he said, before she'd said anything at all. "I know I should. I've been sitting here for an hour telling myself—"
"You don't have to go in there," Isla said. "That's why I came down."
She pulled a stool over and sat, so they were both sitting, and gave it a moment. Down the hall a radiator knocked twice.
"I want to ask you about the painting," she said. "Not about last night. Just the painting."
Theo's face did something complicated.
"I didn't even look at it," he said. "That's — I've thought about that for four hours. I stood in that room, and I didn't look at the painting. I've looked at that painting every week since February. It's the only thing in this building anybody talks about. And I walked in and I didn't see it at all."
"That's not a failing. That's your brain doing exactly what it's built to do." Isla took out her phone. "So, look at it now."
He flinched.
"They're photographs," she said. "Just the canvas. There's nothing else in the frame, I promise you that."
He took the phone in both hands.
And then Isla watched a young man's grief get shoved bodily out of the way by something older and more useful, which was the trained eye, because Theo Lindgren had an MFA and nine years in clay and he could not help himself.
"That's not—" he said.
He turned the phone. He pinched the image open and dragged it. He went to the next photograph and the next.
"This is finished."
"Tell me how you know."
"Because it's resolved." He said it almost angrily. "The horizon's down where she kept saying she wanted it and she could never make it sit there, and it — look, it sits. And she got the depth. She's been chasing depth in the fog since February, she said the whole canvas was a wall and she needed the wall to have a behind to it, and she'd get halfway and it'd flatten out and she'd scrape it." He looked up. "She scraped it on Sunday. I was in there Sunday afternoon. It was mud. It was gray mud with a horizon in it."
"You'd testify to that?"
"Yes." No hesitation at all. "Yes, I'd — yes."
"Keep going. What else."
Theo went back to the photographs, and Isla could see him not wanting to and doing it anyway.
"She didn't paint like this," he said slowly. "This is — you'd call this alla prima. Direct. One shot, wet into wet, you put it down and you leave it. Dana couldn't do that. She hated that she couldn't do that. She'd talk about it. She built everything up in layers and she killed half of it every time and she'd been fighting this canvas for nine months, and the reason she was fighting it was that the subject wanted a kind of speed she didn't have in her hand."
He stopped on one of the raking-light shots, the one where the difference between the lower third and the upper two-thirds showed like a tide line.
"Somebody else did the top," he said.
The radiator knocked again. Isla did not move.