“So, you are a witch.”
She looks the part, even now, with her implausibly colored hair ruffling in the breeze. My gaze catches on it until she speaks, her face demanding my full attention.
“I take that as a compliment, but you’re not the first to say so. Most of the people who’ve read the books I’ve chosen for them have told me I got it exactly right.”
“Is this about being right? Because I have no problem admitting you’re right about a lot of things. I know I’m a disappointment, and my family definitely deserves better. So they’re lucky they’ve got you. You can give them some books.”
She folds her arms across her chest, my eyes following the movement and lingering. “I have, of course.” She doesn’t budge. “Your great-uncle didn’t think you were such a disappointment. He left you half the farm.”
That heaviness is back, trying to weigh me down.
I force a smile. “You heard about that. I may be a disappointment, but I’m a generous disappointment. I’m giving it all to Theo. He’s the one who wants it. He’s the one who’s worked for it. Case closed.”
She surprises me by taking a step toward me.
“Your uncle wanted to give half of it to you. You won’t honor his wishes?”
“What do you want from me?” I ask, somewhere between baffled and pissed. While this woman knows my twin sister, she doesn’t really know me. The only thing she knows about me is what happened on the worst day of my life…and anything else Bianca and the others have told her.
Which, yeah, is probably a lot. I’m the one who doesn’t know her. She’s a mystery that’s haunted me for years.
She pokes me in the chest. “I want you to realize it’s time to grow up and be a man.”
“Did you just poke me?” I ask, laughing.
“Yes, and I’ll do it again.” She does, half a smile on her face. “You should feel lucky I don’t actually knee you in the balls.”
She goes in for a third poke, but I wrap her hand up in mine. I like it there, and from the way her pupils dilate, she doesn’t hate it either. “You could try kissing me again. I liked that better.”
I hadn’t planned on saying it, but then again, I don’t plan ninety percent of the things I do and say.
My pulse picks up as I wait for her response.
She doesn’t pull away, but she doesn’t tip her chin up for a kiss either. Staring up at me, she says, “If you read the book, I’ll kiss you again. But don’t give up the farm until you’ve thought it through. If you do that, it’ll be like turning your back on this place forever.”
I stare at her in disbelief. “You’re bossy.”
“I’m determined.” She wrenches her hand from mine. “They need you more than you think, Bianca especially. She’s lonely. She almost married the mayor, for goodness’ sake.”
“I wouldn’t have let her do that,” I say. “I had a few contingency plans.”
Rhett Gallagher’s a sleaze in a suit, and there’s no way he’s good enough for my twin sister.
I’d think so even if he weren’t the asshole who tattled on me for selling moonshine in high school.
In fact, there’s only one guy I know who might be good enough for Bianca—my buddy Giovanni. Our nonnas were best friends, and he used to come to town with his family every summer when we were kids.
The last summer he was here, when I was thirteen, I dared him and Bianca to kiss, because I knew he was sweet on her.
He’d shoved my shoulder, but there’d been a glimmer in his eyes, like I was giving him exactly what he wanted, and Bianca hadn’t objected either. She’d just leaned in and laid one on him.
I would have teased them more about it, but our nonnas got into a public argument at the farmer’s market so bad it ended with them hurling apples at each other.
It’s still gossiped about in Apple Ridge, although not nearly as much as the car accident. No one knows what started the argument, but there’s no denying it stuck.
Suddenly, the Cafieros weren’t our friends anymore, and they definitely weren’t coming back next summer or any summer.
Still, Giovanni and I have kept in touch, and he’s a good guy—a solid guy who’d put himself on the line to do a friend a favor.