“Yes.”
“Cassian. I could cry. Zayn might be taking Nikolai’s place.”
“He carried it home.” I was already laughing. “In his pocket.”
“Stop it, please.”
“He named it Winston.”
At this point I was bent over holding my stomach. “You people are ridiculous.”
I looked up at him, and the fondness in his eyes softened instantly as they met mine. Maybe it was because he knew exactly what I meant, how not-so-ridiculous they were, but how they loved each other. So effortlessly, and without conditions. I wasn’t sure I’d ever seen that before. I had experienced my fair share of siblings, and the memory brought no fondness to my eyes, or laughter to my lips.
I hated how just the thoughts of them tried to trigger the memories of my past, but I didn’t hate what Cassian had. It was like the consolation for what I had and experienced, and as he smiled at me, cleaned off the tears from my cheeks, I couldn’t help but be more than grateful. Through his stories, I could almost feel what a loving home looked like.
The realization stayed with me as the city slowly transformed around us. Buildings grew taller, cleaner, and definitely more expensive. And for a second, I saw glimpses of the life I escaped.
Then the theater came into view, and my breath vanished. It wasn’t a theater, it was a palace pretending to be one. Massive marble columns towered above the entrance, with crystal light spilling across polished stone. Everything seemed to belong, except me, and suddenly I felt out of place. My stomach tightened, the warmth I’d carried throughout the drive vanished, replaced by something colder, older.
My eyes began to scan everywhere, the entrance, exit, any possible threat. What if someone recognized me? What if someone knew him? What if I embarrassed him? What if everyone could see I didn’t belong here? The car stopped, and I couldn’t move. I didn’t register Cassian climbing out of the car or coming around to open my door. It wasn’t until the cool air drifted inside and his hand appeared, that I came back to the moment.
I looked up at him. “I don’t think I belong here.” The confession escaped before I could stop it, and his expression changed instantly. It wasn’t pity, it was never pity with Cassian.
“Look at me, Phoenix. Just me.” Those impossible brown eyes held mine completely. “You never have to be afraid again. Not with me. Never with me.”
The words wrapped around every frightened part of me. Each one gentle, certain, and unwavering, like a promise he intended to keep.
“Tonight,” he continued softly, “you don’t have to watch the room.” His thumb brushed across my knuckles. “You don’t have to look over your shoulder. You don’t have to prepare for something bad to happen.”
Everything else disappeared, and there was only him. Only Cassian.
“Tonight,” he murmured, holding my gaze, “all you have to do is look at me.” Then he smiled so warmly, so beautifully. “Just me.”
And for the first time since we’d arrived… I smiled too. “Just you,” I said, and watched him nod. Then I placed my hand in his, and followed him inside, more certain now, after the things he’d said, that I’d follow him anywhere.
Chapter Twenty
Aria
The moment we stepped through the enormous glass doors, I realized something was off. Not wrong exactly, just… unexpected. The theater was empty, well, I wouldn’t say it was the abandoned kind of empty, because everything was still absolutely heavenly. Crystal chandeliers bathed the lobby in warm golden light, fresh flowers decorated polished marble surfaces, and staff moved quietly through the space with practiced elegance. Every detail suggested preparation, anticipation, and importance, but there were no crowds.
No women in designer gowns gathering near the staircase, no wealthy couples sipping champagne, or clusters of guests discussing the performance. It was just us.
I opened my mouth to ask about it, then immediately closed it again. Overthinking was already winning tonight. So instead, I stayed close to Cassian as we crossed the lobby together, my heels clicking softly against the marble floor, as a woman behind the reception desk smiled the moment she saw us.
“Good evening, Mr. Vanderhart,” another employee said as they stepped forward. “Miss Quinn, welcome.”
I smiled, trying not to be more awkward than I already knew I was. The warmth in his expression caught me off guard. He wasn’t studying me, judging me, or trying to figure out who I was or why I was there. He simply smiled and welcomed me like I belonged, and that made some of the tension in my shoulders ease a little. A second employee collected our coats while another handed us our tickets. Every interaction was kind, professional, and surprisingly personal. By the time we approached the theater entrance itself, my nerves had calmed considerably.
Unfortunately, my brain had not, because why was it empty? Had Cassian rented the entire theater just for us? Surely not. Then again, this was Cassian. The same man who somehow treated impossible things like they were normal Tuesday activities. Maybe annoyingly rich people rented entire theaters the way normal people reserved restaurant tables.
The thought was interrupted when I felt him lean slightly closer beside me. “Stop spiraling.”
I nearly jumped as my head snapped toward him, finding his eyes dancing with amusement.
“I’m not spiraling,” I lied.
“You absolutely are.”