Page List

Font Size:

She answers and her bright smile is immediate. “Hey, I didn’t know I’d see you tonight.”

She’s wearing a pair of thermal pajama pants and a … you got it … Christmas-themed top with candy canes all over it, a pair of fuzzy socks, and her hair is piled in a messy bun on top of her head. She couldn’t look cuter or sexier to me.

“I just got home from practice and thought I’d stop by.”

She waves me in and shuts the door behind us.

I step into her living room. She has papers spread over the coffee table. I assume it’s her students’ final projects. “How’s the grading going?” I ask.

“Slowly. But I’m more than halfway through now. Between tonight and the grading I do during class tomorrow, I’ll have them done by the end of the school day and have final grades by Friday.” She smiles. “Which frees me up for our shopping tomorrow night.”

I freeze. Shopping.

I told her I’d go shopping with her tomorrow night. Shit.

When my agent presented the opportunity to sign and hang with my teammates, I’d been too exhausted to think about specific plans, and now I’m fucked.

“Are you okay?” Holly asks, staring at me in confusion.

“Ah, hell,” I say, rubbing the back of my neck and frowning. “I’m so sorry, Holly. I forgot all about shopping tomorrow night. I got a call from my agent about an important opportunity, and I agreed to go sign a bunch of sports merchandise tomorrow evening.”

Her eyes open wide. “But you promised you’d help me shop tomorrow night.”

“I know, and I’m sorry, but I can’t pass up this opportunity.”

Her eyes that normally glitter with happiness dim, and my stomach twists with something that feels suspiciously like guilt. Deserved guilt. But if I pull out now and my teammates—my captain—find out I bailed, that’d be a massive step backward in becoming part of the team. I know how rare these spots are and considering how new I am to the city, I need to show up.

“I already agreed,” I tell her, knowing the words are as lame as they sound. I have no idea how to make this right.

Her lips turn downward, hurt shadowing her features. “Technically, you promised me first. Is this signing optional?” she asks, hope in her voice.

I shove my hands into my pants. I could lie, but not to her. “Technically it is. But it’s a team bonding opportunity, not to mention they pay well.”

She narrows her gaze. “Don’t you bond all day at practice?” she asks. “This is important, Clay. Like bringing joy at Christmas to kids who otherwise wouldn’t have any.”

The disapproval in her voice cuts like a knife, harking back to the early days of us meeting. But a push for Christmas, no matter how valid, raises my defenses. That’s what my parents always said. Year after year.

But Clay, it’s Christmas, you need to be with me. I deserve your time more than your father.

But Clay, it’s my first year married, you should want to be with us during the holiday. Your mother doesn’t need you this year.

Anything for one to hurt the other.

I hated being pulled in two directions then, and I dislike it now.

My chest grows tight and the urge to push back against her judgment is overwhelming. “I feel bad about the kids but …” My parents’ voices ring in my ear, and the emotions I’ve felt for the holiday for most of my life return. “Christmas is just an empty holiday that everyone pretends is important, but it all boils down to stress, family bickering, and tacky Christmas decorations.”

Holly’s eyes shift to the Christmas tree beside her, and I see she’s looking at the ornament I bought her on our date. It’s a beautiful piece, and it means something to her and to me. It’s the first Christmas-related thing that has made me feel happy in years.

Regret burns through me, and I take a step closer. “Holly, no. I didn’t really mean that. I just …” Got triggered, I think, and am about to explain.

“It’s okay,” she says, but when her gaze shifts to mine, I’m gutted by the sadness in her green eyes and the disappointment in her expression. Disappointment in me. My words have done more damage than my decision to go to the signing.

She wraps her arms around herself in self-protective mode. “Don’t worry about shopping tomorrow night. I understand.”

“I’m sorry.” For the choice I made and the stupid words I can’t take back. The apology is pathetic, not nearly enough for hurting her, and I curse myself for letting my past emotions get away from me.

“Thanks.” She turns toward the coffee table, stepping away, but the distance she’s created is so much bigger than a few feet. “Listen, I’d better get back to work if I’m going to get all of these papers graded by tomorrow.”


Novels you may like ...