Page List

Font Size:

“But we didn’t have dessert.” He opens the refrigerator and removes a covered dish. “Lucky for us, I have a sweet tooth, so there’s cheesecake.”

My lips lift in a grin. “Well, it’s not homemade cookies, but I guess it’ll do.”

“You’re such a brat,” he says, smiling at me softly and in my stomach, butterflies take flight.

While he sets the dessert on the counter and cuts two slices, I notice a small tin box on the counter. Curiosity gets the better of me, and I reach for it. My fingers have just brushed the lid when I realize that I shouldn’t touch it without permission.

“It’s okay,” Clay says, suddenly standing right behind me. He reaches around me and grabs the box. He flips it open to reveal it’s full of index cards.

“What’s on them?” I ask.

“Recipes.” He takes one out and shows it to me. The writing is in cursive, and the edges are yellowed with age. “This was Gigi’s recipe box. She kept all of her favorites in here.”

I carefully examine the gingerbread recipe. “I love this. You still have her with you after all this time.”

“She loved gingerbread. She used to make it every Christmas because she knew it was my favorite.”

There’s a crack in his voice that makes my heart ache. He just exposed a vulnerability that I want to understand better. “It seems like you have some good Christmas memories from when you were a kid.” I hope this topic doesn’t have him raising his walls.

He takes my elbow and leads me to the kitchen island where two plates sit waiting for us. We sit side by side, and I pick up my fork. Assuming his silence means he’s not going to reveal anything more, I’m surprised when he speaks.

“I did love Christmas back then, just like any kid does, I guess. I spent the holidays with my parents and Gigi. They were the only family I had, but that was enough. We had our traditions—gingerbread cookies and movie night and opening one present on Christmas Eve while the rest were opened in the morning. Back then, the holidays were all about family, and it meant everything to me.”

My heart skips a beat because I know something bad is coming.

He pauses, taking a bite of his cheesecake. I do the same, and it’s delicious, but I hardly notice. I’m waiting for him to continue, to tell me more about what I suspect he rarely talks about.

“Gigi died when I was nine.”

I push my plate away and place a hand on his arm. “I’m so sorry.”

His gaze has been on his dessert, but he turns to look at me, and in his brown eyes, I see a well of grief. Even after all these years, it hurts him to think of it.

“It was tough,” he goes on. “She lived with us and helped raise me, so losing her was like losing a parent. And I loved her so much.”

I swallow hard. “And that’s when you stopped liking Christmas? When you lost her?”

His smile looks brittle. “Not quite. It hurt to celebrate Christmas without her, but I still had my parents, and we tried to keep the old traditions alive, and for a couple of years, it worked. Then, when I was twelve, my parents divorced and it was messy.”

Something tells me that’s an understatement. “What happened?”

He shrugs. “It wasn’t one specific thing, I don’t think. They just grew apart over time, resentment set in, and by the time they finally split up, it was hard to believe they’d ever loved each other at all.”

I think for a moment. First, he loses his beloved grandmother, and three years later, his parents get divorced, throwing his life into further chaos.

“They officially separated two weeks before Christmas. And that was the beginning of the bitter, angry fighting that I was forced to endure every December from then on.” He rubs his hand over his face before continuing. “Don’t get me wrong, they fought all the time after the divorce. But over time, I ended up being the catalyst for so many arguments, I began to feel like the reason they hated each other.”

I clasp his hand and squeeze tight.

“But Christmas was the worst. It was as if they each only wanted to spend the holiday with me because it would hurt the other. Those old family traditions I mentioned? They were replaced by Mom ranting about Dad wanting me with him and his new wife just to punish her, or Dad telling me that my mom was bleeding him dry in child support payments.” He shakes his head. “It continued that way all through my teen years until I was old enough to refuse to spend the holidays with either of them ever again.”

I knew Clay had to have a reason for disliking Christmas, but I never imagined it started when he was just a teenage boy. I feel for him and wish his parents understood the damage they did by being so selfish. As a result, they turned a young boy who appreciated and enjoyed the holiday into someone who hates it because of the negative memories they saddled him with.

“They stole the magic of Christmas from me,” he says, sounding so sad that I pull him into a hug.

He leans into me, and I can’t help but think about the little boy who got excited over his grandmother’s dessert and no doubt eagerly ripped the wrapping paper off his presents with a joyful smile on his face. He deserved better from his parents.

“Can you stay tonight?” he asks as he pulls away.


Novels you may like ...