Page List

Font Size:

“But a man can dream.” He winks, and my heart skips a beat.

Yeah, my body is definitely on board with taking this further. “I’ll consider the cookies,” I tell him.

“I’d better head home,” he says. “But thanks for the sweet treat.” His heavy-lidded gaze meets mine, and I wonder if he’s referring to the hot chocolate or the kiss. He grins and walks out.

I blow out a deep breath, torn by my decision to pull back. But getting involved with my neighbor has serious drawbacks. I know this firsthand because my ex-boyfriend moved into my neighborhood eighteen months ago, along with the woman he’d left me for. Though we’d broken up four years ago and I’m over him, the betrayal still hurts. I trusted him and thought we had a future together. I loved him.

Travis and I met in college and dated seriously until after he graduated, a year before me. He began his career as an architect while I was still a student, and the change meant we were apart more than we were together. I thought we’d weather the year since the strain on our relationship was temporary.

I was wrong. He fell for one of his new coworkers and ended our relationship so suddenly I felt like I had whiplash. We went from together to over in an instant. Now, I’m forced to see the two of them around the neighborhood, and it’s even more awkward because not only do they seem deliriously happy together, but she’s visibly pregnant.

What if Clay and I sleep together and things don’t work out? I’ll be forced to see him often and if he moves on with someone else, they’d be right next door. Am I jumping to possibilities that may not happen? Yes, but like I said earlier, I’m pragmatic.

What I need is a second opinion. I pick up my phone and pull up my VIP contacts, then tap my best friend’s name. She already knows about Clay. We spoke after my first disastrous run-in with him, and then again after the potluck so I could vent about being stuck working with him on the toy drive project.

Madison answers on the second ring, and I waste no time filling her in. “I was decorating his house as planned, and he shows when I’m halfway through. I thought he’d complain, but he didn’t. Not much, anyway. Then, he helped me.”

More than helped, really. He’d seemed genuinely bothered to see me up on the ladder, and his bossy attitude was more of a turn-on than I ever would have imagined.

“That’s unexpected from the guy you said hates Christmas,” Madison says, and I hear the curiosity in her voice.

“No kidding! And afterward, I invited him over for some hot chocolate—”

“Is that a euphemism for something?” she asks, laughing.

I chuckle. “No. I made us hot chocolate. I didn’t intend for it to lead to more, but the next thing I know, his lips are on mine.”

“So, he kissed you?”

“Well, yeah. You don’t have to sound so surprised.”

“Aww, I didn’t mean it that way. It sounds like he’s going to give you the best Christmas gift of all,” she says, and I can picture her waggling her eyebrows up and down suggestively.

“I’m not so sure that’s a good idea,” I say, even though the idea of sleeping with him causes heat to spread throughout my entire body. “We live right next door to each other.”

“On a pros and cons list, I’d say that one goes in the plus column. Having him so close just makes it easier to hook up. You send one text, and he’s there in seconds.”

That does sound convenient, but … “If we sleep together and things go bad between us, it’ll be awkward after. It’s bad enough that Travis lives in Northfield with his wife,” I remind her. “At least he doesn’t live on my street,” I continue. “I see him at community events or if he’s out walking with Jenna, but I manage to avoid him. It won’t be as easy with Clay.”

“Maybe things won’t end badly with Mr. Grinch,” Madison says. “It doesn’t seem like you really know much about this guy, other than that fact that he doesn’t like Christmas. Is that really a deal-breaker for you?”

I consider her question. I love the holiday, and I can’t imagine dampening my enthusiasm for it because I’m with a man who doesn’t feel the same. But then, I think about Clay helping me decorate his own house earlier this evening. He might not appreciate Christmas but outside of our first interaction, he hasn’t tried to dim my light.

More than that, I can sense that there’s more to his dislike for the holiday than he’s shared with me so far. After all, he’d had good Christmases as a child. I want to know what changed for him, why he stopped seeing the magic and started to look at the holiday with disdain. I want to know who he is deep inside.

“You’re right,” I say. “Not necessarily about sleeping with him, not right away, but maybe I need to get to know him better before I write him off completely.”

And tomorrow seems like the perfect opportunity.

CHAPTER NINE

Clay

“You know, a fake tree would be much easier,” I say, as I follow Holly through a grocery store parking lot where dozens of trees are set up in rows, leaning against a wooden frame that keeps them upright.

Holly stops walking so suddenly that I nearly barrel into her.

She spins around and glares at me with fire in her eyes. “What’s wrong with you?” she asks. “Are you crazy?”


Novels you may like ...