Her eyes flare wide, but it’s too late; the cat’s out of the bag, and my insides are flooded with warmth.
“I thought you didn’t keep track of my career anymore.” I stare down at our joined hands and blow out a breath. “To be honest, I figured you’d wiped me from every part of your life.”
When Eloise reaches for the water on her nightstand, I lean across her and hand her the bottle. She takes a couple of sips, attention fixed firmly on me.
“Just because we didn’t have contact beyond the divorce doesn’t mean I didn’t think about you or check on how you were doing.”
I try not to let my mind get ahead of itself. A couple of Google searches don’t mean shit.
“Gabriel saw you were viewing my Instagram stories and blocked you without my knowledge. We had a fight when I discovered what he’d done, and I unblocked you and changed my password.”
That statement definitely has my head spinning out.
“What?!” I announce, immediately regretting my raised voice.
She sets the bottle back down on the nightstand and pulls her hand from mine, leaving me feeling empty.
“Gabriel always knew I never loved him and …” Eloise trails off again, and I pull her hand back, resting it in my lap this time.
“Lo, you can’t begin a sentence like you did and then abandon it there. What about Gabriel?” The bitterness in my tone is unmistakable when I say that asshole’s name.
“I …” She starts and then stops again.
“You what?” I prompt, my heart beating fast enough for the both of us.
She chews on the inside of her cheek. “He resented that I wouldn’t sleep with him before we got married when he knew that I’d lost my virginity to you when we were in college. Gabriel was fixated with—”
“Wait.” I hold up my free hand, the room starting to fall away around me. “Hold up there, Honey.” I’m smiling—I know I fucking am. “Did I just hear that right?”
A coy grin plays on her lips. “You did.”
I rise to my feet because if I don’t, she’ll be beneath me in seconds, and I’ll be begging her to kiss me with my lips hovering over hers.
“You didn’t sleep with him?”
She shakes her head once, and I scrub a hand across my jaw, anything to suppress this cheek-aching grin of mine.
Watching Gabriel hit on my girl whenever we traveled to France made me want to put him through the nearest wall. But knowing that Eloise never slept with him, even after they got engaged? I probably shouldn’t feel as satisfied as I do.
“Does that mean I’m still the only guy you’ve been with?”
I know I’m pushing my luck right now, and it would mean she lied to me during the fight we had in her apartment the other day, but Eloise doesn’t have to answer the question just because I asked it. Curiosity makes me wonder if she will though, and I brace myself for the only response I want to hear.
She looks mildly amused at my angst as I wait patiently for her to say something.
Anything.
Her lips twitch, and a brightness returns to her eyes. “That’s a very caveman-like question to ask, especially since we aren’t together anymore.”
Still standing, I round the bed and lean down, dropping my hands on either side of her ass. My mouth ghosts her ear. The temptation to seal my lips over hers and claim a kiss is strong. But she isn’t ready for that.
Yet.
“Us being together isn’t a prerequisite for me to act like a caveman when it comes to the only woman I’ve ever loved. Roughly translated: I don’t need any fucking excuse to claim you as mine.”
nineteen
. . .