“Thank you, Jess.”
“You’re welcome. I take full credit for you and Wade getting together, you know.”
“I don’t remember you doing anything,” I said, mostly to tease her.
“I gave you a free latte at the Harvest Festival and sent you toward the fire department booth to find Wade. That’s strategy. That’s matchmaking.” She looked enormously pleased with herself. “Mrs. Pruitt thinks she gets the credit, but she showed up five minutes after I’d already deployed you. I was first.”
“Deployed is a strong word.”
“Deployed is the correct word.” She topped off my mocha from a thermos she’d brought with her. “Of course Maeve’s been telling people she masterminded the whole thing from the Shamrock. She absolutely did not. I have receipts.”
“Literal receipts?”
“I have a group text thread going back to your first week here, and it’s timestamped.”
“Does it matter who did what?” I asked. “The important thing is that Wade and I are together now and you can all move on to focus on your next matchmaking project.”
Jess rolled her eyes. “You may have a point. Happy holidays, Theo. Try not to set anything on fire tonight.”
She moved on to her next victim, and I watched her go with a lot more affection than I’d expected to feel for a woman who’d assigned me a coffee order based on my face. When I’d arrived in Clover Ridge I hadn’t even known her name. Now I considered her a friend. And whenever I stopped at her coffee shop my cup was waiting on the counter, usually with a message about Wade written on it in purple marker.
My boyfriend found me standing by the tree a few minutes later. He was coming off a shift and still wearing his fire department uniform. We shared a quick kiss, mindful of nosy eyes watching all around us, then he took his glove from my hand and pulled it on while he looked around at the lights and the crowd filling the square.
“You brought my glove,” he said.
“You left it on the counter.”
“I know,” he said smugly. “I left it there on purpose.”
“You left your glove on purpose?”
“I wanted to see if you’d bring it.” His shoulders relaxed. “You did.”
“That’s a very elaborate test.”
“It’s not a test. It’s a pattern. You pick up my things and bring them to me, and I pick up your things and bring them to you, and neither of us talks about it, because talking about it would mean admitting we’ve turned into the kind of couple Frank warned me about.”
“What kind of couple did Frank warn you about?” I asked.
“The kind who are so annoying in love it makes everyone else jealous.”
He laughed, the real laugh, the full one I’d spent weeks chasing and now got to hear most mornings across a kitchen table in a house that belonged to both of us. I leaned into him, and he put his arm around me, and we watched the crew finish the tree while Mrs. Pruitt worked the crowd with a tin of cookies, looking like a queen surveying her kingdom. Over by the cocoa booth, the Gallagher brothers were arguing about the cookie contest, which Wade said had been discontinued after an incident nobody would describe either.
That morning, on my way into town, I’d dropped off a tin of my own at the fire station. It had taken me three tries to get Aunt Constance’s thumbprint cookies right, mostly because her recipe card assumed I knew what “a good handful” meant. I’d left the third batch in the oven a little too long on purpose.
Frank and Nate walked past on their way to the fire department booth, and Frank nodded at us the way he nodded at everything, acknowledging our existence without committing to an emotion about it.
“Hey, Theo, those cookies weren’t bad. And I noticed that you overbaked some for your guy here.”
Wade smirked, but he didn’t say anything. He tightened his arm around my shoulders and pressed a kiss to my temple, neither confirming nor denying that I’d made special cookies for him.
Frank cleared his throat and looked at a spot somewhere over my left shoulder. “I also hear I talk too much, kid, at least when I think nobody’s listening. I was wrong about you two, and I’m man enough to say so once.”
“Only once?” I asked.
“Don’t push your luck,” Frank said, and he clapped Wade on the shoulder.
“Hey, did you hear that Maeve framed the Facebook post Mrs. Pruitt made when Theo took the house off the market?” Nate asked. “She wrote ‘Wade Calloway’s Emotional Breakthrough, October’ on the frame.”