My eyes close on the first bite. Pillowy gnocchi with the creamy pink sauce tastes ridiculously good. “Okay,” I say, already ready for another bite. “This is incredible.”
He wags his brows and walks back to the stove with an air of confidence.
“Sounds like we both have a dinner date,” Londyn murmurs.
I watch his broad back for a beat too long. “Whatever,” I sigh, with a slight shake of my head. My fight is fading. Even though I know I can’t let go, my heart is slipping, and I force myself to look away.
“We’re ready for the weekend. If you think of anything else we need to do, call me.” I close my laptop and start stacking things. “Have fun tonight.”
“You too,” she sings and hangs up.
Once the table is clear, I gesture toward the piano. “Mind if I play?”
“Are you kidding me? I’ve missed hearing you play.”
I blink. “No, you don’t.”
“Every time I came over and you were playing, I made Brody hang around until you were done. I’d come up with a dumb excuse, like I wanted to play Xbox.”
Heat creeps into my cheeks, and I look away. I remember those days. When the guys would come over, yelling over their games in the back room. I would practice extra long those days, hoping I was annoying them.
I pad over to the piano and settle on the bench, the lake stretching out beyond the glass. This is the perfect spot for it. Keaton follows, leaning against the curve of the piano.
“Did you miss playing?” His voice drops. “Those three years?”
I go still. I don’t talk about my time in jail. Not with anyone. It’s a chapter I keep locked away.
My gaze drops to the keys. I press one down, and the sound hums through me like a current. My pulse quickens, my mind already considering the next note.
I exhale. I’m not sure why I want to tell him. It’s like that single note is pushing me forward.
“There was an upright piano in the dining hall. The first few days I was there, I’d stare at it to avoid making eye contact with anyone.” I pause. “My roommate was a woman in her forties. Betsy.”
I smile, remembering her. She was my bright spot in a dark place. Although she was in prison because she had murdered her husband after catching him cheating, she became my jailhouse mom.
She also believed I was innocent.
“A couple of weeks in, a fight broke out at lunch. A big one. It spread fast, like a chain reaction. Screaming, fists flying, food everywhere, guards slamming people to the ground.” I press my lips together. “I was terrified I wouldn’t survive my time there.”
I play another key, needing the fix to keep going.
“I couldn’t leave, or I’d get into trouble. So, I walked over to the piano, sat down, and started playing. It wasn’t tuned, but I didn’t care. I was somewhere else. Somewhere safe. At least in my head. I started to sing to myself.”
I swallow hard.
“When I finished, I braced for the chaos behind me. But it was…silent. Completely. That never happened in there.” A quiet laugh slips out. “I thought I’d screwed up. But then Betsy stood up and started clapping.” I glance over at Keaton. “And then everyone joined in. Even the guards.”
“Shit,” he mumbles. “That’s wild, Wrenlee. But I’m not surprised. When you play, you have a hypnotic effect.”
I blush. “Whatever.”
He comes over and sits beside me on the bench. I scoot left to give him room. Our legs brush, and I try not to focus on how my body reacts.
“You have no idea the power in those ten fingers.”
I curl them into fists. They were supposed to be my whole life until that life was ripped away from me. I force my fingers to relax, pressing down another key, anything to keep the what-ifs from creeping in.
“What happened next?”