A heavy pit forms in my stomach.
“You sure she didn’t come home?” he asks.
Her cheeks pink. “I checked our cameras to see when she got home. I, uh, like to keep an eye on the neighborhood.” She gasps, realizing something bad might have happened to Leslie. “I didn’t think anything of it, you know these young kids today. Is she in trouble?”
“It’s still too early in the investigation. If you don’t mind, I’ll send an officer over to get that camera footage.”
“Of course,” she says, then turns to hurry across the street. An officer standing outside follows her.
The officer turns back to us, taking out his small notepad. “Yeah. I’m going to need you to tell me everything.”
I bite the inside of my cheek, then steady my voice. “My brother died last week in Hazel Falls. They ruled it an accident, but there’s more to it. He was supposed to meet with Leslie a couple days later. She had information—something that could clear my name.” I draw in a shaky breath. “But he never made that meeting. That’s why we’re here. And now, I think, whoever killed him is looking for the proof that Leslie has. Or, worse, has her.”
The cop studies me for a beat, and I can see in his eyes the moment it clicks. “You’re Wrenlee Reed?”
I nod.
He glances at Keaton, eyebrows rising. “Jesus Christ. Wasn’t it your dad she went to prison for killing?”
“Mike, she didn’t do it,” Keaton says, his voice sharp.
He holds his hands up. “I’m not here to cast judgment. Just trying to understand…” He puts his pen on the paper, ready to write. “Who are you working with at the Hazel Falls precinct?”
“I’m not,” I say. “They don’t believe it was a murder. But they also didn’t believe me ten years ago.”
He sighs. “Fair enough. For now, I’ll call this in as a possible abduction and request surveillance footage from the neighbors. We also have this guy”—he nods toward outside—“and if he knows something, we’ll squeeze it out of him. Good job taking him down.”
Keaton’s lip ticks up, giving me a quick glance before he sticks out his hand. “Thanks, Mike. Appreciate it. Do you mind keeping us updated?”
In hindsight, yeah, good job. But in the moment, dumbest decision ever.
He shakes his hand. “What I can, I will.”
We head outside toward Keaton’s truck. He reaches for the passenger door, pauses, and turns back to me.
“With Leslie possibly missing, you are not staying in the hotel tonight. I’m taking you back to get your stuff, and you’re staying with me.”
“Keaton, that’s not—”
He puts a finger over my mouth. “Did you hear a question mark at the end of that sentence?”
Damn. I’m in so much trouble.
CHAPTER TWENTY-TWO
Wrenlee
I drop all my bags on the bed in the room Brody slept in. With a heavy sigh, I crawl onto it and lean against the headboard, pulling Brody’s pillow tight against me. The pillowcase smells like detergent, but I can feel his presence in here with me.
“I wish you weren’t dead so I could wring your neck,” I mutter to the ceiling. “Nothing about me being in this town, with Keaton, is a good idea. But you left me with no choice. I have to finish what you started. And now, Leslie’s missing. Everything is a mess.”
Closing my eyes, I try to pull up memories of Leslie back in high school. We weren’t friends. She was one of the popular kids. She ran in my brother’s circle. We only knew each other from English class; that was it.
I grab my laptop and flip it open, opening a couple of social media sites and typing in her name. She has them all set to private. The only mutual friend we have on Facebook is Brody. I click on his profile. Messages flood the screen, post after post from people who figured out that he’s gone. There are hundreds.
My heart hurts reading them. So many people loved him. He was also hated by many. It came with the job. I can’t help but click on the profiles that wrote nasty messages.
“Mark Monroe doesn’t like you very much,” I whisper, scrolling through his page. “What’d you catch him doing?”