I have a feeling it’s not her, but I grab my phone out of my back pocket and search her name anyway. When the address pops up, I lift my head.
“She lives in Everton.”
The town on the other side of the lake. I glance out the window at the darkening sky. Showing up uninvited after nine isn’t a good idea.
“Looks like we’re going to Everton in the morning,” Keaton says.
“We?” I ask, wondering when this became a we thing.
“Your brother is dead, Wrenlee. I’m not going to let you go over there by yourself?” He shakes his head. “I don’t fucking think so.”
I sigh. “Pick me up at eight.”
CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE
Wrenlee
“This is it,” I say, stopped at the curb, staring down.
“How do you know?” Keaton questions, stepping next to me.
“One of Brody’s pictures. A curb with painted numbers on it. I’ve been staring at it for two days wondering why he took it.” My eyes drop to the faded paint. “It’s her. Leslie has to be JB.”
We climb the four steps to Leslie’s front door, and I can’t stop wringing my hands. I’m nervous, and I shake out my fingers. I spent years convincing myself the truth was locked away tight with the person who lit the match.
It’s hard to build a stable life if the ground that it’s built on is jagged. Forgetting this place was a way to level it out. But now that the truth could be a few feet away, I feel like I’m about to throw up.
I exhale sharply. “Am I working myself up over nothing? What if she has no clue and this is a complete waste of time?”
Keaton stops on the last step and turns to me. “We won’t know unless we talk to her.”
He’s right, I’m spiraling. Wanting the truth so badly that I’m suffocating myself in the what-ifs. I force my shoulders to relax and step up to the door. The house is charming, with a baby blue exterior and a wraparound porch. I press the doorbell and wait.
No answer.
Keaton knocks twice. The second knock pushes the door open with a long, eerie squeak. We exchange a glance. He didn’t knock that hard.
“Leslie?” he calls out as he nudges the door open wider.
The moment we catch a glimpse inside, my heart stops. Couch cushions tossed, lamps knocked over, drawers pulled open with papers scattered all over the floor. I rush inside, pushing past Keaton, calling out her name, darting from one room to another. Each looks worse than the last.
“Don’t touch anything,” Keaton warns, close behind me. “I’m calling the cops.”
I hesitate in the hallway, the last room we’ve yet to check. It has to be her bedroom. Please don’t let me find her dead. I push open the cracked door. Keaton is right behind me. Relief slams into me when there’s no sign of Leslie—until a voice cuts through the air. A man’s voice. Keaton holds his finger to his lips.
“I told you, I looked everywhere. There’s nothing here.” A pause. “Yeah, I checked out there, too. Nothing.” Another pause. “Yes, asshole, I looked in the toilets. Fine! I’ll check again.”
I freeze and jerk my head toward Keaton. We’re standing right in front of the bathroom. He grabs my hand and opens a closet door, pushing me into hanging clothes. I step aside a little, giving him some room to squeeze in. The door clicks softly shut. Blackness surrounds us. It’s hard to tell if there has been foul play or if this guy just trashed the place.
I’m pressed against Keaton’s back, my heart pounding so loud I swear it’s echoing through the walls. I rest my forehead against his shoulder, attempting to stay calm. He reaches for my hand behind him and holds it. Despite my initial reaction to pull back, my need for security outweighs my sentiments for him.
Outside the door, the guy mutters, “If the asshole doesn’t trust me, he should’ve done this his damn self. He acts as if I have all the time in the world.”
Porcelain slams against the tile floor, and I jerk at the startling sound.
“Nothing. Like I fucking said,” he growls.
Heavy footsteps thud past us. After a couple of seconds, Keaton turns, and I can’t see his face, but I feel the heat of his breath, the presence of his large body. He slips his phone into my hand.