She nods. “The only thing I remember about that night is his dad getting home early and shutting the party down.”
That doesn’t clear up anything. “Who’d you go with?”
“Oh, geez. Um…if I wasn’t with y’all, I was with the soccer girls.”
I make a mental note to look at all the girls’ names on the team. One could be JB. She stands, grabs her crossbody bag off the table, and slings it over her shoulder.
“I’m meeting some girls from the gym for drinks. Want to come?”
My stomach twists just thinking about drinking. “Did you not hear about my night out the other night? I should stay away from public spaces while I’m here.”
“I heard he deserved it,” she says with a wink.
She leans in and gives me a hug. “Wrenlee, nothing I say will ever make up for the damage I caused, but I try to be a better person every day because of it.”
I hope that’s true.
“Thanks for coming over.”
She’s almost to the door when she stops and digs into her bag. “Not sure if you want this, but here’s a picture of Brody. A couple of days before he passed away.”
She turns the screen toward me. It’s the two of them, heads together, with the cheesiest smiles. Brody hasn’t looked that happy in years. At least not that I’ve seen. Tears burn in the corners of my eyes.
“Can you send that to me?” I ask, grabbing my phone.
Once I have it, I can’t stop staring at it. I lean against the rail, searching his face for any sign he was faking. He looks in love. Not sure how to process that.
I glance up as Harlo climbs into her SUV. It suits her; bold and in your face. Everyone sees her coming, and I’m certain that’s the point.
The information in my head jumbles together. I understand why they have massive whiteboards at police stations. It’s an easier way to connect dots. Who did what? Who said what?
My brain hurts.
My gaze lifts to Keaton, standing outside his truck. He waits for Harlo to leave the parking lot before jogging across the street. I’m already running on empty, I’m not sure I have anything left for him.
He looks up at me. “I figured out who JB stands for.”
I straighten. “Who?”
“Jelly Bean.”
“What?” What does that even mean?
“I’m coming up,” he says, already heading for the stairs.
By the time he reaches my room, I’ve stepped inside, leaving the door open behind me. He walks in and shuts it. When I turn around, I have to force myself to retreat slightly, because this gorgeous grown man is still high school Tripp underneath it all. A new name doesn’t make him a new person.
This room is too small.
He bites back a knowing smile and drops onto the edge of the bed.
“Tell me what you meant,” I say, leaning against the wall.
“Brody called someone Jelly Bean in high school. But I can’t remember—”
“Leslie Moore,” I cut him off, remembering right away. She used to complain to me in English class all the time about the stupid nickname, wishing he would stop. As if I could get my brother to stop doing anything. “Do you think that’s who he was talking about? Does she even still live here?”
He shakes his head. “She moved away after high school. Not sure where she went.”