Page 49 of Wildfire Lies

Page List

Font Size:

“Bullshit!”

His eyes snap to mine, and his jawline hardens. “Wrenlee, you can think what you want, but I swear on my Nana’s grave, I didn’t tell a soul. I was just as surprised when people started talking about it.”

I blink. I remember going to his Nana’s funeral in ninth grade. It crushed him.

If it wasn’t him, who did? The confusion clouds my thoughts for a beat, then the trial comes to mind. I cross my arms tight across my chest.

“Well, you ended up telling the entire world.” The words fall out, raw and jagged from where they’ve lived in my chest after all these years.

I still picture him on the stand, stating we had “got together,” and the attorney asking him to explain what that meant.

Never in my life had I wished for a sinkhole to open and swallow me. Needless to say, the ground stayed solid, and I was stuck there, listening to him broadcast to the entire courtroom and everyone that was watching it on video that we had slept together. And to compound the humiliation, his lawyer insisted on mentioning that he was the one who took my virginity.

His jaw clenches, but I don’t give him a second to respond.

“You humiliated me. You made people think I was some unhinged girl out for revenge, like I was bitter and unstable instead of…heartbroken.”

He drags his hands through his short beard, a vein pulsing in his temple. “I was eighteen, too, Wrenlee. I didn’t want any of that to happen. They made me testify. And fuck,” he growls, “I had lost my dad. They had you on camera walking into my house with a gas can. Minutes later, it was up in flames. What was I supposed to think?”

Silence settles between us. A decade of anger. Of heartbreak. Regret. We stare at each other, surrounded by old ghosts and fresh wounds. I blow out a shaky breath and peel my eyes away, stepping over to the bumper of his truck. I lean against it, staring out over the city I once loved.

The city that threw me away.

Keaton walks over and sits beside me. “I’m sorry,” he murmurs. “I’m sorry for everything. You didn’t deserve what happened. And for what it’s worth, I know you didn’t kill my dad.”

The confession lands hard. My eyes flutter closed, but it doesn’t stop the sting. It’s ten years too late.

“I’m the reason Brody was here,” he adds.

I turn, my brows pinched. Brody already knew I was innocent, so why would he come here and stir up trouble?

“Eight months ago, I got a letter. No name, no return address. Only a message saying you didn’t start the fire, because they have proof of who did it. They said the person was still living in Hazel Falls and was someone we went to school with.”

My heart stutters. “Someone from school did it?”

He shrugs. “That’s all it said. I had no idea what to do with it. So, I called Brody. Since he’s a PI, I figured he could tell me what I should do. Then out of the blue, he was knocking on my door a couple days later.”

Of course he was.

Someone knows. Why? Why stay silent all this time…then tell someone but remain anonymous?

“Huh?” I look over at Keaton. “Do you think it was a joke?”

There are assholes in this world, I wouldn’t put it past them.

“Still not sure. But one of the last things Brody told me was that he might’ve found the person who wrote the letter.”

As I put the pieces together, I softly whisper, “JB.”

His head snaps toward me. “You know who wrote it?”

“No,” I sigh. “But Brody was meeting someone named JB. They’d met a few times, but it was always in the woods. In his last entry, he said they were ready to tell him everything.” I pause, my voice quieter now. “That was June eighth.”

“He was dead two days later.” Keaton’s hands curl into fists. He pushes off the truck and starts pacing. “I told him to be careful.”

Nobody could tell Brody anything. I tried. So did our parents. His job was a constant dance with danger. Spying on cheating spouses one day, chasing down kidnappers or con artists the next. He thrived on adrenaline and wasn’t afraid of anything. He felt he was invincible.

Until he wasn’t.


Novels you may like ...