More like I’m her number one enemy—definitely her number one regret. My cheek still stings from the slap that echoed through the church.
I sigh. “That’s Wrenlee.”
They all snap their heads her way, then back to me. “The Wrenlee?” Jasper whispers.
As if there are two of them.
I hate that they only see her as the woman who went to jail for starting a fire that killed my dad. They don’t know the real her. Only the lies the town told.
Brody was close to the truth.
And it might’ve got him killed.
“I didn’t know her back in the day because you guys were younger than me, but I saw pictures. That is not the same woman,” Trent states, staring at her with a mixture of curiosity and surprise.
“I’m sure jail changed her,” Jasper adds.
“From a cute run-of-the-mill girl to a drop-dead gorgeous woman?” he snaps back.
He’s not wrong.
She’s changed. I didn’t even recognize her at the church. Had I not overheard her talking, I would never have guessed it was her, especially from behind. The petite woman in a tight black dress, with curves that grab your attention, buttery-blonde hair pulled back in a ponytail, and a colorful floral tattoo down her right arm…definitely not the same girl I secretly had a crush on growing up.
She had mousy dark-blonde hair, she didn’t wear makeup, and her clothes were always conservative. But she had a natural confidence that made her sexy. She wasn’t trying to impress anyone. She was captivating because she was smart and didn’t care what anyone thought of her. But she was off-limits because she was my best friend’s sister. I had long given up the idea of asking her out.
Until that night.
“There goes number four,” Davis says, pulling me out of my thoughts as I watch her slam down the shot glass. She has to be feeling it, the numbness creeping in. That’s what she’s chasing, something to dull the pain.
“It’s gotta be hard seeing her,” Jasper says. “We could go somewhere else.”
Leave? That’s the last thing I’ll be doing.
“Nah, I’m good staying,” I reply, my eyes locked on her. She’s going through hell right now, and I’ll give her this moment, but when the night ends, I’ll be the one to guarantee she gets home safe. I owe Brody that much.
The bar gets crowded as the night drags on. I’ve been nursing the same beer since she got here. If it wasn’t for her, I’d have tossed Jasper my keys and been hammered by now. The guys stopped asking if I wanted another round an hour ago. They know it’s because of her, they just don’t understand.
And I can’t explain.
I keep watching, waiting. Be done with the night, Wrenlee. Instead, she sits there, staring at her phone, scrolling through whatever is on the screen. I can’t see what she’s looking at, but I’m guessing it’s pictures of Brody. Every so often, she wipes away a tear.
“Hey, fire starter,” Matt yells out from across the room.
My hand freezes midair from taking a drink from the warm beer. Guess he figured out who she was. I peek over at Jasper, who’s watching me like a hawk. He shakes his head once, a silent warning not to get involved.
My attention jumps to Wrenlee. She stops looking at her phone and maintains her gaze straight ahead at the liquor bottles behind the bar, not moving a muscle.
“Yeah, murderer, I’m talking to you,” Matt adds, his voice louder now.
Why’d he have to go there? She just lost her brother. Dumbass is begging for a fist to the face. Mine, to be exact. I push off my stool, heat simmering beneath my skin. He might be drunk, but there are consequences to actions. Jasper and Davis stand with me.
Then Wrenlee laughs. Not in amusement. It’s sharp and hollow, the kind that would make most people uneasy. She sounds unhinged. Shit, this can’t be good. She slides off the stool and walks toward him. I’m impressed she can walk straight.
Numerous eyes follow her. She stops in front of him, and he’s wearing this cocky grin. There’s another slap coming. My feet are ready to jump into action because this won’t end well.
What happens next takes a mere two seconds, no one saw it coming. She cocks back her fist and lands it square in his nose. There’s a collective gasp. Matt’s head snaps back, and when he straightens, blood is already streaming down his face.
Damn, girl has a wicked cross jab.