“If he’s awful, we’ll rescue you,” Kate promises.
“It won’t be awful,” I insist.
The rest of the night passes with wine, takeout containers scattered across the coffee table, and nonstop conversation.
For a little while, surrounded by my girls and laughter and city lights outside the windows, I almost forget how badly I miss my footballer.
When it’s time to head out, I check my phone and have a missed call from James and a text.
James
Sorry for the massive delay. I haven’t stopping missing you the entire time. Call me when you can.
Relief washes over me. I let the past emotions dictate my feelings. I knew things felt different with James. They feel real. I need to trust that if it’s going to work.
Suddenly, I can’t wait to hear his voice.
When I finally get home, I crawl into bed, Chloe curled beside me, and call James.
“Good evening, gorgeous.” His voice is soft, almost tentative, and some of the tension I’ve been carrying all day loosens.
“Good morning,” I respond.
“I owe you an apology,” he says.
The tension snaps right back into place. “Okay.”
“I was distant. I needed to clear my head.”
I hold my breath, waiting for whatever comes next.
“I had a moment of weakness.”
My heart gives a hard thud. “What does that mean?”
“I’m an idiot; that was a poor choice of words.”
Relief rushes through me, but it doesn’t last long.
“What I mean is, I let everything get in my head. Ben heard me on the phone with you.” He lets out a breath. “I don’t want to lie to him, to your dad. Or anyone.”
Guilt presses down on me. I’ve been so wrapped up in wondering whether James still wants this that I haven’t thought enough about what keeping me means for him.
“Your dad believed in me when I was a young lad. He got me here, and I feel like I’m betraying him. And therefore, my team.”
I close my eyes. Dad and Mom’s warnings from earlier come rushing back, only now they sound different coming from James. He isn’t pulling away because he doesn’t want me. He’s scared of what wanting me could cost.
A moment passes before he speaks again.
“No matter how hard I try to convince myself that this is wrong, it’s not. Deep down, you see something more in me than a footballer. You brighten my days, and I don’t want to be in a life without you in it.”
My throat tightens, and I pull the covers closer even though I suddenly feel anything but cold.
“If we can keep this quiet, we can figure this out. We need to be careful. We don’t want to hurt anyone along the way.” He pauses “Because Christ, you… ”
He stops himself, and my heart stutters at whatever he almost said.
“You matter to me, Allie. More than I know what to do with.”