“Let me refresh your memory,” she huffed with a cross of her arms, her hands sliding from my grip far too easily. I felt an icy chill all of a sudden, like the warmth had been leeched from the room. The words dripped like acid off her tongue, my stomach churning from the aching burn. “You’re nothing but an unwanted nuisance.”
“WHAT?!” I yelled, my voice ringing out louder and far rougher than I intended; It made Scarlett flinch.
Fucking flinch.
That tiny movement broke my heart, all the way down to my soul.
I’d heard her say that disgusting phrase before, at seven years old, when she’d broken down after I found her crying alone on the playground. It was just more nonsense that her mother had spewed, the icy blade of her cutting words forever leaving their mark on Scar’s adolescent brain. When I recounted the story to my own mom, she had reminded me that hurt people hurt others to make themselves feel better; but at that moment, I didn’t feel pity for Guiliana like my mom had tried to inspire.
All I felt was disgust and the stomach twisting rush of abhorrence that Scarlett was crying.
Again.
They were just words, but they were weighted ones that pinned down my angel’s wings all throughout her life. They not only held power over Scarlett, but destruction. Even just the remembrance of that slurred speech had her body shaking, on the verge of tears. Guiliana Alessandro was dead, though, and as far as I knew, they didn’t have good cell service in hell.
Taking a deep breath through my nostrils, I schooled my furious expression and asked, “Who said that to you?”
The hurt echoing in her eyes was clouded by incredulity, her lips parting in utter shock. “You did.”
What. The. Actual. Fuck.
“I did what, Scarlett?” I felt like a fool for asking when I could clearly see where this was going, her upset expression the only evidence I needed. She thought I had texted her those heinous words. But I was still in disbelief, needing her to say it so I could completely understand the situation. Never in my goddamned life would I dare to say that, to do something so fucking horrific to her. “You think I texted you that?”
“I know you texted me that.” Her small nostrils flared in anger, her shoulders straight and rigid. Tears built in her oceanic eyes but she was fighting them back. The blue in them looked so much brighter from the redness taking over; her voice became shaky. “I saw it, I remember it. Daphne’s even seen it. You sent it, Finn.”
Nausea rolled in my stomach, my esophagus beginning to burn.
I would never hurt her like that, would never even think of saying something so damned horrendous when I knew the ramifications. All I’d ever wanted was her, so why the fuck would I call her an unwanted nuisance?
Just the term alone made me want to gag—nuisance.
Like she was nothing but an annoying pest.
Fuck.
She was anything but that.
A tear fell, the salty water rolling down her cheek until I batted it away with my thumb, surprised that she didn’t pull away from my touch. She wasn’t walled up completely, at least not yet. I wanted to hold her, to kiss her and soothe her and tell her that it was just a misunderstanding … but she really believed I had done that, and I needed to get to the bottom of it.
“When did I say those words to you, Scarlett?”
“Right before you moved here,” she sniffled, the sound so damn heart-wrenching that I wanted to scream. “Right after you got drafted.”
That timeline made no sense.
When I was first moving here, the only messages we exchanged were our ramblings of excitement that I had achieved my dream of playing professional hockey. The Bisons had drafted me during my junior year at Princeton, and it had all worked out so perfectly. We’d made all sorts of plans for her to show me around the Bay, our phone calls and texts becoming more frequent until it was almost time for me to move; and then they just stopped …
Like she’d fallen off the face of the earth.
It had been weird and completely out of character for Scarlett to just shut me out like that; our competitive friendship never got to the point of being downright nasty or hurtful. There was always the underlining of respect in our banter—at least on my end, there was.
So you could imagine how shocked and hurt I was to find out that she not only shut me out but she’d blocked me. On fucking everything, to the point that I had to resort to using burner accounts like some stalker to even keep up with her.
But now it was all coming full circle, the picture becoming clearer the closer I studied it.
“Scarlett, I know you’re probably not going to believe me, but I’m still going to say it.” Now my eyes were shut as I tried to keep a rein on my anger, all those years we were separated flooding back to me in a hailstorm. We could’ve had so much more time together, so much more of us. Fuck. I turned to the side and took her shaky hands into mine, her angelic face still stained with tears. “I never have—and would never—say those words to you. I fucking swear that wasn’t me. I know I don’t have an explanation for you to believe me, but fuck—” my voice broke as another tear trailed down her cheek, her torment evident. “I would never dare to hurt you like that. I’d rather rip out my own heart than say something even remotely close to what you just said.”
And that was the fucking truth.