Page 69 of The Games We Play

Page List

Font Size:

And there I stood, directly in front of her apartment door with a giant batch of Maddox’s mom’s famous brownies, an oversized toy for Darla, and a potted orchid in my arms.

It was now or never, and I sure as fuck hoped she wouldn’t call the cops.

I didn’t know how well just entering held up in court, after all.

I gently rapped on the door with my knuckles, my sneakers digging into the linoleum as I bounced on the heels of my feet. I was dressed in a black team sweatshirt and light grey sweatpants that’d hopefully seduce my sweet angel, with my ball cap backward.

Yeah. Bringing out the big guns tonight.

I had the strategy all mapped out: Phase one, ply my blue eyed cherubic goddess of a creature with the fudgy brownies. Phase two, bribe the dog with the oversized toy to keep her occupied on the floor since there was only room for one girl in my lap and it wasn’t the one with fur. Phase three, the long game—keep Scarlett with my arms and just… stay there.

No rush, no score to settle, just savoring the way she smelled and the weight of her leaning against me under a blanket.

Purely wholesome, strictly cozy.

That was the win.

There was the click of the lock, elation zinging up my spine as the door swung open. “Daphne, what the fuck,” I hissed under my breath, her giant brown eyes looking shocked at my appearance. Her blonde hair was thrown up in a bun and she was dressed in workout clothes, Darla’s bright leash in hand.

“Oh, hey Finny,” Scarlett’s best friend wiggled her fingers at me, opening the door to the apartment wider. A black blur moved toward me at a heightened speed, little toe taps sounding on the hardwood floors as Darla sniffed at my feet in friendly excitement.

Leaning down with an open hand, I let the lab mix lick my palm before I began stroking the side of her neck. She leaned into my touch, the movement so slight yet so endearing that it made my heart warm. “So cute,” I breathed out in awe as the puppy melted.

I’d always wanted a dog, but I could never have one with my travel schedule.

As quick as a whip, Darla’s heart-shaped head locked onto the giant plush toy that’d fallen from my hand when I first saw her. She snatched it up in her maw excitedly, her black ears flexing back until she kind of resembled a seal.

It was so fucking cute.

After a couple of moments cooing over the sweetest little animal, I looked back at Daphne and finally asked in a hushed tone, “What are you still doing here? You’re supposed to be spending the night with Spencer.”

“Plans changed,” she sniffed, her small chin tilting up. “I’ll be seeing him later … I think.”

I frowned, the math not quite adding up. When we’d touched down at the airport earlier that afternoon, I’d heard Vernon tell a few of the guys he was going straight home to spend the night with his girlfriend. That was hours ago—plenty of time for me to get home, shower, change and prep this whole mission. I figured the bag she was carrying meant she was finally headed his way to join him, but the uncertain look in her eyes didn’t match the story at all.

Her doe eyes turned hopeful before Daphne attached the leash to Darla’s matching collar. The lab paid her no mind, just kept squeaking the toy. Daphne then slung her large bag over her shoulder and did a little clap with her hands. “But don’t worry, I won’t ruin your plans, we were just running late is all!”

“This is your house,” I argued. “You and Darla don’t have to leave, Daphne.”

“Oh, but I think we do.” The blonde looked down at my sweatpants and then back up at my face with a smirk. “Grey sweatpants mean business.”

The blood began rushing to my face, embarrassment flooding my bones as Daphne patted my shoulder. “Take good care of my girl,” she huffed and walked down the hallway with Darla in tow, a long black tail wagging happily as she took her new prize.

Taking a deep breath, I squared my shoulders and stepped into Scarlett’s apartment. My lips tilted into a soft smile as I took in the warm, eclectic furniture mixed with plush blankets and furry pillows in the living room directly off the entryway. Patterned rugs lined the hardwood flooring, bringing warmth and comfort throughout the space. Dim lighting came from overhead, the feel of the room cozy and serene as a non sex wax candle burned brightly on the short coffee table.

Just beyond the couches was a large kitchen with marble countertops and a double sink, an absolute treasure to find in the city for a good price. My grin only grew wider when I imagined Scarlett dancing around the open cooking space teeming with well-used pots and pans as she cheffed up a storm.

Taking another step into paradise, I could make out the carefully torn pages of doodled artwork that was plastered to the fridge, scribbly hearts and smiley faces galore. My heart swirled with warm admiration at seeing her love for her pediatric patients reflected in her home and daily life.

There were two long hallways in each direction just off the entry as well, and I was now standing like a jackass in the center, not knowing what the fuck to do from there.

Should I go back outside and knock on the door again and act like I was just showing up now?

Probably; Yes, that would be the smoothest option.

Turning on the balls of my feet, I grabbed the handle of the front door and began to make my exit-slash-reentry when I heard an angel call out my name. “Finn?”

Sheepishly turning around, I held out the brownies and blooming orchid, trying to flash her with my megawatt smile. “Hey, baby.”


Novels you may like ...