Why did he have to be the person who made me feel this way? Out of the billions on this planet, the one human capable of stealing my breath was also the only one capable of shattering me beyond repair.
It was a cruel, sick, and twisted joke played by fate.
It was like I never even stood a chance.
Like the game I was trying to play with him was one he’d already won.
“Scar,” he breathed out, his deep brown eyes dancing in delight. They were always so kind and understanding, even with his teasing jabs. I could look into those pools of obsidian divinity and see the truth in them. I could see what he always saw in me. Something—someone—worth seeing. When he stared at me like I was more than some game he was playing, butterflies came back to life in my chest, their delicate wings matching the erratic beat of my heart. “You made it.”
“Of course,” I chirped and crossed my arms over my chest in the hope that my heart would begin working normally again. “Anything for my kids.”
He smiled at that, his infamous dimples making an appearance. “They’re going to love it.” Finn flung his uniformed arm out toward one of the tables where they were still setting up hockey themed sensory toys. “We planned a whole afternoon of activit—”
“Holy macaroni!” a child-like voice crowed in awe. All heads in the arena turned toward the little girl who was stepping onto the ice. Her usual long, red hair was pulled back into a ponytail and she wore a pair of white earmuffs that made her look too adorable.
It was Taylor Harkins, one of my star patients who had Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome, commonly known as EDS. Her mother—Cassie, who had matching fiery hair—was beaming at her side, hand in hand. Taylor bounced in enthusiasm and asked loudly, “Is that Theodore Maddox?”
“Only one way to find out.” Cassie guided her daughter onto the ice, Taylor’s head looking every which way in shock and awe.
She was only six years old and a complete firecracker with her wants and desires of becoming a professional ballerina. The Prima Ballerina. With her connective tissue disorder, most sports, especially high-contact sports like hockey, would be off limits due to the impact on her body. However, for ballet, EDS was like her double-edged sword, the hypermobility making her joints more flexible and working to her advantage at times.
Her vibrant green eyes met mine and lit up, her excitement over the famous goalie redirected at me. “Miss Scar! Miss Scar!” Taylor practically dragged her mom across the rink, her elation so palpable. Leaning down, I met her halfway as she gave me a loud whisper. “There’s famous people here!”
“I know, I know,” I fake-whispered back, my eyes dramatically looking around us like we were at some zoo with exotic animals. Finn’s stare was blazing into the side of my face and it was a struggle to not look directly at him as I went back to Taylor’s covered ear. “I can’t believe they’re real.”
She nodded her head, absolutely loving that I always played into her shenanigans. This last week she had been fully convinced that famous people weren’t real since she hadn’t seen them herself. I mean, her logic wasn’t that off.
I wasn’t entirely convinced Cher was a real person.
Too fucking perfect to exist.
“I’m going to poke Theodore Maddox and see if he’s real,” she giggled before taking off, her mom’s hand long forgotten. Finnegan was chuckling behind me, the sound so trilling that I wanted to stamp it into a record and play it on a loop.
Cassie gave me a quick smile then jogged off after her daughter. “No poking people, Taylor! Famous people aren’t apparitions!”
More parents and kids started trickling in, chaos beginning to ensue. I turned back toward Finn, who had a wistful, easy smile on his face.
“What?” A nervous laugh trickled out of me, my face growing obnoxiously red because he was still just staring.
His smile turned to a grin, one of pride and admiration. “It’s just nice to see you doing what you’ve al—”
“Finnegan!” an unrecognizable middle-aged man in a custom three-piece suit called, stalling our conversation. His honey-blonde hair was perfectly coiffed and styled like he was on a runway rather than a charity event. Even his leather shoes looked far too polished and shiny, like he could be just a step away from losing his footing. One of his hands held a phone to his ear as he gestured with his other for the Bisons’ captain to join the amassing crowd. “Time’s up, kid, let’s go!”
Finn turned his head to the call and gave a little nod of acknowledgment before he explained, “That’s my agent, Ross Haubernaush, my true right-hand man.” He flashed me a disarming smile that had my legs feeling shaky as he promised, “I’ll introduce you guys after the event.”
“Finn!” Ross called again, his hand motions growing aggressive as more of the event’s attendees arrived.
“You should go.” Another laugh bubbled out, but it was less nervous as the calmness of his presence washed over me.
“See you in a few, gorgeous.” He gave me a dramatic salute with his fingers against his forehead before he jetted off in his agent’s direction. I watched him join Reed Lockhart and Everett Russo, who were already being ushered toward the center of the madness by event staff. Both children and adults flocked to Finn as he moved, like moths to a flame, and basked in his light as he shook hands and hugged babies.
And, fuck.
It was not helping with the whole butterflies-in-my-throat-and-heart situation.
An hour after meeting the players, and Salma’s welcoming announcement, I was choppily skating with Addison’s hand in mine as we pulled Quinn on a mini-sleigh. My coworker’s curly black hair was pulled back in twin top knots, the light pink sweater making her deep umber skin glow in the arena lights. If Addi didn’t always look so nicely put together and effortlessly gorgeous, I’d say she was on the hunt for a Bison instead of a Firebird like she’d originally planned when we signed up for the fundraising.
With some of the children’s physical limitations, skating wasn’t an option; so, we opted for the classics of sledding and even some tennis balls on walkers to make for easy gliding with assistance. Nothing made me feel more complete than seeing my kids experience life for themselves, their giggles filling the entire arena.