Survivor would be a weird thing to lie about, but I wouldn’t put much past Finnegan MacCallum.
As if my thoughts conjured him, another message came through, the notification pinging loudly before I could press the issue.
“Who was that?” Daphne was fully sitting up now, her eyebrows wiggling suggestively. Our friend—and her assistant—Farrah, was getting married in the summer and Daph had just spent the day helping her with venue options, making her all the more romantically inclined to play matchmaker. Those perfectly manicured hands of hers came together like some sort of cartoon villain plotting my heart’s demise. “Was that who I think it was?”
Trying to keep myself from smiling, I nodded my head and opened the message.
Most Eligible Douche
Oh great goddess, can you please bless me with your presence at my game tomorrow?
I gasped, my heart pounding wildly in my chest like a hummingbird’s wings. “What did he say?” Daphne prodded, her large heart eyes pleading for mine and Finn’s love story to unfold.
“He wants me to come tomorrow.” Daph was going to be at the game already, cheering on Spencer from the front row in her favorite spot like she had at the Bison’s opener.
She jumped from the couch, Darla waking with a start and looking at her crazed auntie as she danced in our living room and sang, “Scar and Finny, sitting in a tree! K-I-S-S-I-N-G!”
The pup leapt from her pile of blankets, excitement coming out of her paws as she tapped on the patterned rug. Daphne did a big twirl, her blonde hair falling from the bun as she shook her ass, “First comes love, then comes marriag—”
“I’m not going,” I stated. My best friend’s ass shaking stopped abruptly.
“What do you mean you’re not going?” Now Darla was calm and seated on her hind legs, watching Daphne patiently for a treat.
The silly little texts and his prank gift was one thing. But that was it—just a little thing. Nothing more, nothing of substance. His cute words and pet names were just a part of Finn’s natural charm, even though I melted when he called me sweet angel. But I couldn’t let myself fall into this again.
Daphne started, “Can I just say—”
“No.”
“You don’t even—”
“No.” I sniffled slightly, my nose starting to run. I blamed the air conditioning, always too freaking cold in these places. Clutching the cornicello to my neck, I took a deep, grounding breath.
“Scarlett Antonia—”
“No.”
I couldn’t do it.
Couldn’t let another person have that much power over me again.
He’d shattered my heart years ago with a phrase I couldn’t unsee, so I didn’t even want to imagine how much more it would hurt when he did it this time. But I also just couldn’t control myself. Not when it came to him. It was an effort to not respond to his daily pestering and twenty-questions.
I knew he was bad for me, but I just couldn’t let him go fully … at least not yet.
“Do you really hate him that much?” Daph’s voice was soft and understanding, her huge brown eyes shining.
“No,” I sighed, my heart beginning to ache all over again. “I could never hate him, but I already know what’s going to happen.”
“Oh, yeah?” She lifted one light brown eyebrow, an accusatory look now glinting in her eye. “Did you ask the cards while I was gone or something?”
That made me smile. “No, Daph. I didn’t touch your tarot deck.”
Her expression was gravely serious. “You already know that when reading for yourself, it’s easy to see what you want instead of what’s actually there, babe. Your emotions influence the interpretation of the cards heavily.”
“I know, I know.” It was something we’d gone through time and time again during Daphne’s readings. My internalized emotions tended to make me read into things wrong, expecting the worst to come rather than looking for the positives.
But it was hard to see the light when all you’d ever known was the dark.