Page 124 of The Games We Play

Page List

Font Size:

November 9th, 1998.

“1998,” I gasped in surprise through my bleary vision. “The year we met.”

“You remember.” Now Finnegan was smiling again, a storm of emotions building in his deep irises.

“I don’t think I could forget,” I poked his side and he laughed.

I’d never forget the boy who laughed and played, the boy who teased me until I no longer looked like a sad, fallen angel. The same one who stuck weeds in my hair and called them flowers so I’d crack a smile. The one who would sit with me while we waited for my Nonna to pick me up, the same one who waited for me all these years.

Daphne let out a loud, boisterous, slightly crazed laugh. My gaze immediately went to hers because she was smothering her mouth like she knew a secret, both her and her penguin folding over on the couch.

All the boys had a knowing gleam in their eyes as well, their gazes ping ponging between their captain and the photo in my hand. Finn was just shaking his head and grinning, but Daph was still giggling until she finally asked, “Do you know what else is ninety-eight?”

I thought I was done gasping for the evening, but clearly not, because the shock registering to my system was abysmal.

Ninety-eight.

Finnegan’s jersey number.

All this time.

All this fucking time.

My lips shook as tears trailed down my face and I looked back to Finnegan, who was no longer smiling. His mouth was set in a straight line, slight worry etched on his handsome face as he asked, “Is that too crazy, or just crazy enough for you?”

Flinging myself into his arms, I sobbed like a lunatic as my best friend kept snort-laughing. “Just the right amount of crazy.”

There was clapping and whooping and I think some singing, but I couldn’t deign our friends any response. Not when it felt like my broken soul was reforming all at once, Finnegan’s light stitching the pieces back together. He pulled my face from his chest and that smile was back, so damned beautiful with his two dimples on full display. “I’ve always loved you, Scarlett Antonia Alessandro.”

My palm rested against his handsome face, not a care in the world that the whole room was staring at us. “And I’ve always loved you, Finnegan Killian MacCallum.” I gave him a quick kiss and pulled away to whisper, “Even when you won’t give me back my underwear.”

The crazy man nipped at my mouth. “I don’t see your name on them.”

Another laugh bubbled out of me but was quickly silenced as a pounding on the front door stole all of our attention.

All heads turned, and even Darla woke from her snoozefest.

Theodore was the first to ask, “Anybody else supposed to be coming?”

“No, not that I know of.” Finn’s eyebrows drew down as he stood from the couch. He strode to the door as we waited in bated silence, all eyes looking into the foyer.

The front door flung open the second the deadbolt clicked over and a barrage of reddish-brown barreled through the door, Camille’s faded hair colliding with her brother’s chest.

“Cami?” Finnegan’s voice was shocked. I left the couch, sprinting over to them.

She was supposed to be arriving a few days after Christmas, her room all stocked and ready for the long upcoming winter break from Harvard. Finn hadn’t been able to tell her about their father yet—his sister was still supposed to be seeing him for their usual holiday affairs in Oregon.

But she was here. In California. Now.

What the hell is going on?

“I couldn’t do it anymore.” She was hitting his shoulders with weak arms. “I couldn’t take it.”

Her pretty face was a mess of tears, her cheeks and nose red and raw from crying. My hand rubbed her back as she sobbed into Finn’s chest. “Cam Cam,” my voice was gentle and worried. Camille was known for being dramatic; she was Finnegan’s little sister, after all, but it was a very rare occurrence to see her this upset, this distraught. “Are you okay, honey? What’s going on?”

“Scar?” She left her brother’s arms and dove into mine. I met Finn’s gaze with confusion as I rubbed her back some more. He looked petrified, his gaze wide but concerned.

“Camille,” Finnegan said her full name and that pulled her from her sobbing momentarily.

His little sister squared her shoulders and wiped her snotty tears as she looked between Finnegan and me. Gone was the panic and hysteria, and in its place was surety and determination.

The same determination I saw in Finnegan when he was about to hit the ice.

Camille spoke the words that would damage their already broken family beyond repair. Killian would surely flip his ever loving shit as Finn’s baby sister admitted, “I dropped out of law school.”


Novels you may like ...