Her face falls. “I know.”
I stare at the table, at the coffee ring beneath my cup and the scraps of tissue she’s left everywhere. “No, I don’t think you do.”
She goes quiet.
“I know I should’ve told you about Aiden. I should’ve told Gabe too. I spent months making excuses because I was scared shitless, then convinced myself all those excuses were noble somehow. I was protecting Gabe. Protecting Aiden. Apparently I was the fucking patron saint of protecting everybody, while really, I was just terrified of what would happen if I admitted how much he meant to me.”
My hands won’t stay still, so I rub them over my thighs.
“I know I fucked up. I lied. I hid something huge from Gabe. I kept Aiden in this weird little box where I could pretend what we had wasn’t serious enough to destroy me.” My throat tightens. “But I needed you to be my friend that day.”
Abbie’s breathing hitches, but she doesn’t interrupt.
“I’ve always been there for you and Gabe. Not because I’m keeping some ridiculous score. I do it because you’re my family. If something goes wrong, I’m there. Half the time neither of you even has to ask.” I look down at my hands. “You’d barely been around for months because everything was Paul. But you were happy, so I told myself people disappear up each other’s asses for a while. It happens.”
A tiny sound that might almost be a laugh leaves her.
“Then the first time you really looked at me in months, you looked at me like I was somebody you didn’t even like.”
Her fingers tighten around the tissues.
“You didn’t ask me what was happening. You didn’t give me five minutes to explain that Aiden wasn’t some random man I’d been secretly screwing because I thought lying to everyone was funny. You made him sound like he was nothing to me.”
My eyes sting.
“He wasn’t nothing. He was already everything, which was the fucking problem.”
I breathe through my nose and stare at the opposite wall because looking at her is too hard.
“I was already in love with him. I love Rose. I’d built a swing in my garden for that little girl before I was brave enough to admit why I wanted something of hers permanently at my house. Aiden was looking after me when I was sick, showing up every time I gave him another reason not to. I was terrified because I’d agreed to messing around and suddenly wanted forever.” My voice cracks, and I hate it. “And you didn’t know any of that because I didn’t tell you. That’s on me. But you didn’t even give me the chance.”
I finally turn toward her. “I thought we were family.”
She presses a hand to her chest. “We are.”
“Didn’t feel like it.”
Her hand moves toward mine, then stops halfway. That hurts too. I look away, pressing my tongue against the inside of my cheek until the sting behind my eyes settles.
“I’ve always struggled with feeling like I belong. You know that. Maybe not all of it because I’ve kept a lot more from you than you probably realized, but you’ve known me since college. You knew me when I was still pretending I didn’t give a shit what my parents thought about me. You were there after ballet when I walked around acting like changing my entire life was mildly inconvenient instead of something that ripped me apart.”
I rub at my sternum. “You knew enough to know I already had this thing in me that was always waiting for people to decide they’d had enough.”
She sniffs, nodding.
“And then you told me Aiden deserved better than being kept a secret. And I know what you actually said. I’ve replayed that conversation enough times. I know you didn’t stand there and say Aiden deserved someone better than me.”
“I didn’t,” she whispers.
I swallow.
“But that’s what I heard.”
The pressure behind my ribs turns painful.
“And once that got in there, everything else just slotted together. Every horrible thought I already had. That there’d be too many days where I wasn’t funny or sexy or easy to have around. That Rose deserved someone who didn’t sometimes spend a whole day in bed with the curtains closed. That Aiden would keep looking after me until one day he realized loving me was more work than I was worth.”
Abbie’s crying again, silently this time.