I keep my focus over his shoulder, biting down on my cheek so hard I taste copper. “Nothing happened. We always had an expiration date. And now it’s here.”
“An expiration date?” he seethes. “No we fucking don’t.”
“I think you should go.”
“And I think you should tell me what the hell is going on right now.” I can hear his heaving breaths, feel his eyes on me. “You won’t even fucking look at me.”
I can’t. I can’t look at his handsome face, at the memories of everything we had that I’m about to shatter into a million pieces along with my own heart.
“Tell me what I did wrong?”
The pleading in his voice hurts.
“Nothing. We’re just… done. We were fucking around, and now it’s over. It was just sex. We said nothing would change outside of that, so…” I trail off, battling the urge to run to the bathroom and empty the contents of my stomach. “We’re done.”
“It wasn’t just sex. It was never just sex.” He throws the flowers on the coffee table. They land with a soft thud. I stare at them because looking at him is impossible.
The beautiful petals will bruise.
He turns away, dragging both hands over his face. His shoulders rise with one long breath that he holds.
“Just tell me how I fucked this up; I’ll fix it. I swear I will. I’ll do anything for us.”
I squeeze my burning eyes closed. “There is no us.”
Something inside me recoils from the words the second they leave.
Of all the lies I’ve told, that might be the worst.
There’s an us everywhere I look.
His coffee mug in my kitchen.
The scent of him on my pillow.
Rose’s crayons beneath my coffee table.
A swing hanging from my cherry blossom tree.
“I don’t—” He lets out a shaky breath. “I don’t understand. I thought we felt the same way about each other. I thought you—”
He cuts himself off.
But still. There it is. The thing I’ve been trying not to hear. That we felt the same.
Feel the same.
Because I think we do.
And I wish he didn’t, because he deserves so much better.
“We said we wouldn’t catch feelings. If you did, then… well, I’m sorry.” I shrug, faking indifference I don’t feel when I say, “But for me, we were just having fun. It wasn’t serious.”
Abbie’s words keep finding their way back to me. Circling me like a shark in water. Consuming me.
“Look at me. If you’re gonna do this to me, if you’re going to break my fucking heart, then the least you can do is look me in the eyes while you do it.”
I can’t.