Nerves simmer inside me as I greet his family. “Hi, Mrs. Cole.”
“Oh gosh, call me Catherine. Is that… are you two wearing matching pajamas?” Her expression softens. “When are we gonna have the chance to meet you, dear Lola?”
“Is she coming to see us?” one of Tyler’s sister shrieks.
I throw a glance at Tyler, who watches me back, wiping a hand over his mouth. “Um, I-I don’t know.”
“We would love to get to know you better. It’s been hard for Tyler since his—”
“Okay, that’s enough,” Tyler snatches the phone from me. “Pass the phone to Hazel and Iris so I can say Merry Christmas, then Lola and I will go back to our night.”
His sisters coo in the background, and this time, I can’t contain my laughter.
“You guys are impossible,” he mutters. “We’re watching a movie. Anyway. Love you. Talk later.”
There’s a flurry of Love you! Miss you! Say bye to Lola! And once he’s hung up, he sighs.
“I’m so sorry about that. They can be very intrusive. And intense. And noisy.”
“I don’t mind,” I snicker. “They seem fun.”
“They are. I’m very lucky to have them.” A faint smile stretches on his lips. “You’d get along great with them.”
My heart squeezes at the mere thought of being part of such a close-knit family. Of Tyler even contemplating a future where I get to meet the people who matter the most to him.
No. I will not cry again tonight. “Oh, and why?” I tease to stave off the emotion. “Because your sisters and I are women of roughly the same age, so we must like the same things?”
He shakes his head. “Not at all. Because they’re stubborn and strong-willed, like you. And they love to piss me off. Case in point: they’ve been stalking our social media even after I told them not to, and they keep showing it to our mother.”
I snort. “They’re messing with you.”
He hums. “How about we finish the movie, and then…” He looks at his watch. “Then it’s Santa time.”
Half an hour later, the credits roll on the screen. The clock on my bookshelf displays 11:55.
“Come on, buddy, move.” I gently wiggle my thighs, and Loafy jumps off my lap. “Are you opening my gift first or am I opening yours?” I ask, sliding to the floor and sitting cross-legged in front of the Christmas tree.
He joins me, his knees cracking as he lowers himself. “Whatever you pref—”
“Okay, mine,” I squeal.
I reach for the bag bursting with red and white tissue paper and shove it at him.
“Merry Christmas, Tybear.”
His lips twitch. “Was waiting on you to say something.”
As he plucks the tissue paper out, my heart hammers furiously in my chest. It only arrived yesterday. Right on time.
His face unreadable, he lays the tracksuit jacket on his lap. His fingers brush over the embroidery, and when he looks up, surprise flickers across his features. “Lola…”
“I know you may not coach the girls for long, but I figured we should make your position more official, even for a little while. And worst-case scenario, it’ll make for a nice souvenir. Something to remember us by.”
He runs his fingertips along the outline of the Coach Tyler woven in gold thread beneath the Pine Falls school crest.
“I don’t know what to say,” he whispers, voice thick with emotion. “I love it. I—” He takes my hand, his thumb stroking across my knuckles. “Thank you.”
He slips the jacket on over his pajamas and, of course, makes the ridiculous combination sexy.