I dash to the Christmas tree and pluck a forest green bag stuffed with gold tissue paper from beneath it.
“Lola, this is so cozy.” He peruses my living room, where I’ve scattered candles on every available surface. The TV is on and set on the crackling fireplace channel, and every shelf and piece of furniture I own is decorated with Christmas lights.
“The twenty-fourth is the softest night of the year. Here.” I hold out the bag. “It doesn’t count as your Christmas present, because it’s not midnight yet. And you have to open it now.”
He cocks a brow, removing the tissue paper. “What did you do?” With one hand, he pulls out the matching red pajamas. The wrapping falls away as he holds them up in front of him.
“I wasn’t sure of your size,” I say, “but this looked big enough for you. If you want, you can wear it now and be comfortable too.” When he doesn’t say anything, I add, “I get a new set every year and wear them on Christmas Eve.”
Cracking a smile, he turns the pajamas around, checking them out. “I love them. They’re really cute.”
My body tingles, tiny sparks dancing through me. “You can change in my room if you want. I’ll wait for you here.”
It doesn’t take him long, but it’s enough time for my brain to torture itself by conjuring a hundred images of Tyler peeling off his clothes on the other side of the door.
When he comes out, clad in his new Santa Claus pajamas, I bite my lip to stop myself from sighing.
“What do you think?” He opens his arms wide and spins slowly.
It’s unfair, really, how perfectly they fit him. They hug his shoulders and thighs and calves just right, falling neatly over his ankles, just above his bare feet.
“Adorable. Now all three of us match,” I add, scooping up Loafy.
“Stop.” He slaps a hand over his mouth. “Okay, I’ll give it to you; he really does look a lot less menacing when he’s stuffed into a little Santa shirt.”
Loafy meows in my arms, wiggling to set himself free, and when I put him down, he trots over to Tyler, and rubs against his legs.
Listen. I get it. The apple doesn’t fall far from the tree.
Tyler bends, scratching the spot between his ears, and Loafy arches his back, pushing his head against his hand.
“He likes you,” I say. “Which means a lot considering how he usually tries to attack any guy who sets foot in this apartment.”
He looks up at me. “Any guy?”
“Matt, Oli, and James,” I clarify. “Not a big fan of them.”
A quiet “oh” escapes him. He straightens and walks over to the bag he left on the table, then gently pulls out a package wrapped in Christmas paper.
“Santa stopped by my place and left this for you,” he says, placing it under the tree. “Told me you’ve been a very good girl this year.”
Those damn butterflies migrate south of my belly. “I’m always a good girl.”
He hums, a low rumble. “To be determined.”
Butterflies morph into scorching heat. Can we make that determination right now? Because I’ll show him exactly what a good girl I can be.
“You didn’t have to get me anything,” I breathe, veering back to safer territory.
“Says the woman who got me pajamas and a Christmas present,” he rasps, nodding toward the second bag next to the gift he set down.
“Take it up with Santa. I had nothing to do with it.”
He hums again, a mischievous twinkle in his eyes.
Laughing softly, I light the candles on the dinner table. “I’m warning you, I didn’t make anything fancy tonight. I ordered the traditional Christmas lasagna from Oli’s restaurant and plenty of cookies from Mia’s for dessert.”
“That sounds like heaven to me. What can I do to help?”