Page 57 of Frost and Found

Page List

Font Size:

Before I can shake myself out of this daze, he steps out and closes the door behind him.

Well, he didn’t say I couldn’t make hot chocolate, did he? Even if I’m better off limiting sugar around a flare-up, I refuse to give up one of the very few things that fills me with joy and holiday cheer. It’s only for two months a year anyway.

And if I busy myself doing this, I won’t be ruminating over what the last twelve hours have been like.

Okay, that’s a lie. It doesn’t stop me from thinking about it at all, which is really problematic. In fact, that’s all I do: think about it. About his arm and how he wouldn’t let me move an inch away from him. About how his body heat soothed me more than my heating pad. This man likes to pretend he’s detached and impervious to emotion, but as it turns out, he’s hiding multitudes that I’m now desperate to uncover.

I smile as I whip the cream, humming to the tune of “Jingle Bells.”

I wasn’t mentally prepared to witness this side of him yesterday. Gentle and attentive. Soft, almost worried. As if, perhaps, an old version of him seeped through the cracks of the hardened man he is now. As if that younger Tyler was determined to remind him that he still exists, however deeply buried he might be. That despite his general grumpiness and big statements on loathing love, he’s still that younger man who craves to show up for people he cares for.

But why would Tyler care for me? Too-romantic, head-too-far-in-the-clouds, too-stubborn Lola. The things I love most are the things he seems to have no patience for. Why would soft and gentle and tender Tyler come out around me, then? Maybe because he went into autopilot. Those old instincts kicked in the same way they did when his ex-wife had flare-ups. He didn’t do it for me, or because he cares about me. He did it simply because he knew what to do and the steps and motions were second nature to him.

My gut twists at the thought, but I brush the sensation aside. I have no right to be disappointed or feel rejected over a man who’s literally doing more for me than my own family. Doesn’t matter the whys or the hows. His surprising knowledge of what I needed and his willingness to listen when I had to verbalize it should be the only things that count.

It’s strange, talking to a man who actually wants to understand my syndrome, how it affects me, what helps. Outside of my friends, every guy in my life has been quick to tell me how I feel instead. My dad with his “it’s just period pain” and “you should probably work less.” Doctors haven’t been much better. “Have you tried eating healthier?” and the usual “maybe you have a low pain tolerance.” As if I didn’t already know my own body.

But Tyler? He listened. He learned. He understood. That alone would have been enough for me to hit replay in my head for the rest of today.

As I wipe my hands on a towel, my phone buzzes on the counter and James’s contact photo appears.

Snorting, I pick up.

“I get a serotonin boost every time I see this picture of us dressed as each other for Oliver’s Halloween party,” I say as a way of greeting.

“You did rock the glasses look pretty well.” He laughs. “Though if you’d used a fake pair, you wouldn’t have bumped into furniture all night.”

“It’s called committing to the bit.” Though that stunt gave me a migraine for a full day. Worth it. “Is everything okay?”

“Yeah, I wanted to check in,” he says. “Haven’t seen you in a while.”

I rack my brain for a memory of the last time we saw each other. Damn. That alone gives me my answer.

“Our last Friday night dinner was forever ago, huh?”

“We got busy,” he replies softly, though I know he’s the one who always bends his schedule around ours.

With Matt splitting his time between the store, his sister, and Zoey, and Oliver and Charlee always disappearing into the wilderness chasing their next piece for their work at Wild Planet, and me working nonstop on the festival, our friend group has struggled to keep our one dinner a week commitment.

I don’t like it. I don’t like it at all.

For as long as I can remember, it’s been Oli, Matt, James, and me. They’re the brothers I never had. The ones who got me through the best and worst moments of my life. Who made me belly laugh in the middle of French class and weep when they all chipped in to help me buy my store. Who I saw heartbroken, grief ridden, and devastated on more than one occasion, the four of us sticking together for weeks, all sleeping next to one another in a makeshift bed of couch cushions and piles of blankets.

Who, over time, brought me the sisters I’ve always dreamed of through Charlee and Zoey. But, I mean, come on. I did everything for these guys. It’s the least they could do to say thank you. I vetted their choices, of course, but I did raise those boys well, so it wasn’t a big surprise that they picked the most amazing women to be their partners.

And so we’re down to two. James and me, single and with so much more free time on our hands than the others. Until Kate’s Book Club approached me and I had to ditch our one-on-one dates.

“Why is it so hard to follow through with plans when you’re an adult?” I whine, guilt coiling in my gut.

James chuckles, the sound warm and familiar. “Because we’re idiots who think we can do everything at once?”

I let out a brisk laugh, leaning back against the counter. “I’m sorry I’ve been MIA lately.”

“Nothing to apologize for, Lols. How’s the festival prep going, by the way?”

I groan. Of course he’d ask. He’s so thoughtful and kind and a good friend, but the answer to that question is way too loaded right now.

But I sum it up as best as I can. “We’ve picked the book. Now the real work begins. Permits, vendors, locations, activities, etc. But it’s been fun, you know? And I’ve had some help too recently, which makes things more—” Difficult. Interesting. Complicated. “Simple.”


Novels you may like ...