“I’m only stating facts,” she says like she’s been reading notes from my file. Tyler Cole: Thirty-eight years old. No kids. Professional grump. Hobbies include being a part-time asshole, crocheting, and occasionally narrating sexy books. “No offense,” she adds with a small smile.
“None taken.” I sip my coffee. “Being called grumpy is probably justified after this weekend.”
That earns me a surprised laugh from Charlee. “Self-awareness.” She nods. “I like that.”
Lola shifts in her seat beside me, and a waft of her perfume, the perfect blend of sweet and spicy, tickles my nose. She smells like gingerbread cookies straight out of the oven.
She snags a leather-bound notebook and a pen from the table before clearing her throat. “So…” She finds a fresh page. “Kate wants a story that’ll appeal to a wide range of romance readers and highlight our leads’ chemistry. The key is a balance between a solid plot and good—”
“Spice,” Charlee interrupts. “We want good spice.”
Mia nods, her eyes bright. “With emotional depth, obviously. But definitely steamy.”
“We’ve narrowed the selection down to four options.” Lola shoots Charlee and Mia a glare, then leans forward and picks up the stack of paperbacks at the center of the table. She places them in front of her and holds one up. “You know all of them, obviously, since you’ve narrated them,” she says to me, “but I’ll give you a quick summary to refresh your memory. This one is from Casey Lane. It’s a retelling of How to Lose a Guy in Ten Days, with a grumpy-sunshine trope.”
I snort. “Sounds like a familiar dynamic.”
Lips twitching, she puts the book down and goes for another. “This is an enemies-to-lovers workplace romance. We have a paranormal romance, and this one’s a second chance.”
I move closer, a twinge in my gut at the sight of the distinctive colorful covers. It’s been a long time since I’ve seen illustrations like these. A man and a woman kissing or close to it, looking at each other as if nothing else in the world exists. I used to find those covers cute. Used to easily picture myself on them, back when I still believed love and romance were real. Now, I know better.
“Any thoughts?” Lola asks.
Looking up, I find her watching me. “Um…” I grab the workplace romance and flip it over so I can peruse the blurb on the back. “I have no idea what constitutes a good romance novel or what readers gravitate toward these days.”
Rosie frowns. “But you narrated all of these.”
“I did. Doesn’t mean I’m an expert of the genre.” The words come out harsher than I intended, and beside me, Lola tenses. “I mean… Narrating is a job,” I go on, forcing a softer tone. “I’m tasked with bringing books to life with my voice. There were a couple of trends a few years back. I recorded a lot of cowboy and millionaire romances, but I’m sure it’s changed since. I’m probably not the best judge now.”
“Actually…” Lola rests her hand on top of mine.
It’s brief, a small touch that vanishes before I can take my next breath, so quick that I could easily have imagined it. But the heat on my skin tells a different story.
“Maybe that’s exactly why your opinion matters,” she continues, oblivious to my confusion. “Because you’re an outsider. If we pick a book that you could see yourself reading, it might have broader appeal.”
Charlee snorts. “This is the book club read of the biggest event in the country, and we’re going with the least painful option according to a man who hates romance? That’s our metric?”
“No, that’s not what I meant.” Lola sighs, burying her head in her hands. “But the five of us can’t come to a final decision.” She looks at me again, like she’s genuinely asking for my input. “You have a more objective perspective.”
I hold her gaze, her irises shimmering with specks of navy and indigo. I hadn’t realized until now but her eyes are actually blue. A moonless night kind of blue, so deep that looking into them feels like diving into the unknown.
Ironically, it’s exactly what these last two days have been like.
With an exhale, I say, “fine.”
One at a time, I scan the back covers.
I wasn’t a fan of the office romance when I recorded it. Paranormal doesn’t appeal to me, and if I remember correctly, there’s a love triangle, and I’m not sure this would play well for a wider audience.
When I read the first line of the blurb of the second chance romance, my heart stalls in my chest. Memories of the recording sessions come flooding back. It took me hours to finish this story. So many facets were all too familiar.
“You don’t like this one?” Lola asks.
“That was my pick,” Zoey says. “I love a good marriage-in-crisis situation. They’re always so romantic. The yearning. He grovels a ton in this book. I love it. Nothing better than a man who begs.”
Yeah, nothing better. And super realistic too. Everyone knows that when a marriage is on the rocks, all it takes is a little groveling to fix it all, right? I’m sure Amy would still be head over heels for me if I had begged her a little harder not to give up on us.
Bunch of bullshit.