Nodding, I said, “Okay.”
“Don’t dance with Luke.”
My head drew back in surprise. “Why not?”
Her eyes darted to the barn once again before she pierced me with her blue eyes. “Trust me on this one. Can you do that?”
I took her hand in mine and gave it a light squeeze. “Of course.”
A wide smile erupted. “Great! Now head on into the barn. I’m going to go find my mother’s hidden stash of Oh My God brownies.”
Laughing, I shook my head and started for the barn. Once I got there, I found Caden and Gatlin cleaning up. There were a few ranch hands helping as well.
Gatlin looked up, and when he smiled, it felt like the whole barn tipped.
“Hey, I thought you were looking at the goats?”
With a shrug, I reached for a bucket and started to gather some of the items we’d used earlier during the branding.
Gatlin put a hand on mine and said, “Can we talk? Alone?”
My eyes darted around, and I noticed no one was paying any attention to us. When I looked back at him, I replied, “Sure.”
He looked relieved. “Let’s head to my office.”
Taking the bucket from my hand, he set it down, laced his fingers in mine, and guided me through the barn. The way my body responded was both thrilling and confusing. I felt like I was in damn high school again.
Gatlin ushered me into his office, and the moment I stepped inside, he shut the door. My heart was pounding so loudly in my ears, I had to wonder if he heard it as well.
Placing a hand to his heart, he laughed. “My fucking heart is pounding in my chest.”
He took my hand and placed it there, and something electric raced through my body.
“Do you feel that?”
“Your heart?” I asked.
Gatlin nodded. “Your touch makes me feel alive inside, Em.”
My mouth fell open slightly, and I fought to find words.
“Before you say anything, let me talk first.”
I nodded, because that was all I could do.
“First of all, I’m not dating Berkeley. We’re not together, and we never have been. Not in a dating kind of way. We did have a friends-with-benefits arrangement, but I broke things off with her because she wanted more, and I didn’t. This was before I even met you. Well…I made up my mind to break things off before I met you. Then you showed up, and between work and trying to find ways to be around you more, I kind of forgot about Berkeley. I told her things were over that day outside of Anna's. And by the way, she never sat on my face and…well…you know.”
“But she wanted something more than sex?”
He closed his eyes and nodded. When he looked at me again, his eyes were pleading. “I swear, she gave me no indication of that anytime we were together. And it was very casual, only getting together occasionally. I’m not even that kind of guy! I mean, this makes me sound like that kind of guy, but Berkeley was the only woman I’ve ever had that kind of…uh…arrangement with.”
I shook my head. “Gatlin, what you do in your private life is just that—private.”
“Berkeley told me what she said to you the other night. Is that why you were avoiding me today? Why you blew off my text yesterday?”
Swallowing the sudden lump in my throat, I nodded.
“Did you believe her?”