“Of course,” Officer Martin said. “I’m here to ask the routine questions. It’s peculiar to have people go missing in this town.”
Frank huffed, clearly displeased. Christine rested a hand on his arm, easing some of the rigidity in his stance, though the protective look in his eyes never wavered.
Officer Martin turned back to me. “What did you do last night, after the vigil?”
My mind tried to piece together a response. Thanatos had promised to handle the bodies, and yet the chief of police was here. Should I lie? Would he see through me if I did?
I chose the truth—or part of it. “I went to the cemetery. Mr. Hayes said he had some pictures for me from the funeral.”
“Really now? Well, he’s one of the few who went missing.”
I went still. “That…makes sense. When I got there, I couldn’t find him.”
His mouth set into a thin line, and he slapped a stack of photos onto the bar. The first was of Mr. Hayes. The others were the men who attacked me. The group’s leader held my focus; the friendly face on paper warped into the monster from last night.
He’d tried to take my life, and instead, I’d taken his. Be it my curse, fate, or some divine cruelty, he came too close and paid the ultimate price.
Officer Martin pointed at the picture. “That’s Destin Whitlock. Do you recognize him?”
“I don’t,” I said. “I don’t recognize any of them.”
But I did know Mr. Hayes. My heart twisted while I studied his photo, the man who’d become an undeserving victim. His face carried years, a life halfway through, but still with so much left to give. I didn’t know him well, only that he had a wife and daughter—facts I learned from the way he spoke about them to anyone who stopped long enough to listen.
Were they waiting for him to come home?
I traced his image, the paper crinkling beneath my touch. Whatever Thanatos did to him, it couldn’t have been good. His face might live forever in this file, his story left unfinished, no one ever knowing where he’d gone or what happened to him.
“Are we done here?” Frank asked.
Officer Martin exhaled. “All right. But if any of you think of something, don’t hesitate to reach out.”
He lifted the photographs, then his gaze dropped to my arm. My eyes followed. Claw marks scored the skin there, hard to see against the ink, but enough to make him hesitate. I resisted the urge to cover them. Hiding would make it worse.
Officer Martin looked them over for a moment longer before he turned for the door. The bell above chimed when he left, and I let out a breath I’d held for far too long.
“What the hell was that about?” Frank snapped. “I’ve never seen Roy act like that.”
Christine shrugged. “I’m sure he didn’t mean anything by it.”
“Yeah, right. He barely questioned us, but he went after Seph as if she were a suspect. I don’t get why you mentioned those guys to him. Now he’s got Seph under a microscope.”
“He asked for a full rundown, so I gave it. That’s all. ”
Frank huffed, irritation flaring and fading in the same second. “Okay. I get it.” He glanced at me, softer now. “Still, what’s he thinking…that you killed four people in one night? Ridiculous.”
I let out an awkward laugh that ended in a wheeze.
Christine offered a thin smile. “He’s the chief, sweetie. He’s doing his job.”
“Well, he’s going about it all wrong.” He rubbed a hand over his jaw, then turned to me. “I should hire someone else for the bar. We need more eyes if there’s a killer out there. And with you going back to school in a few days, extra help wouldn’t hurt.”
“Sure,” I said, but my thoughts stuck on an extra person skittering around me, treating me as radioactive. Hopefully Frank wasn’t serious.
He turned back to Christine. “That also means I’ll have more free time to take you out.”
Christine’s smile turned into a real one, and I took that as my cue to leave. I muttered a halfhearted goodbye and headed for my room.
The door clicked shut behind me. I braced my back against it, holding it closed, though I knew no physical barrier would keep out my troubled mind. The ghosts of my past needed no invitation, creeping through the cracks that had festered too long.