“It’s not you,” I tell him.
He closes his eyes.
“I know,” he says. It’s the strangest thing. He says it as if he’s confessing.
Then, behind us, from somewhere deep in the walls of the kitchen, comes a sound.
Knock.
Knock.
Knock.
Three knocks, slow and soft, evenly spaced, from the wall by the stove. It isn’t the pipes. It isn’t the settling of an old house. It’s the sound of a knuckle on wood, patient and deliberate, and it comes from the plaster itself.
None of us speaks.
Luca’s head comes up. Henry’s hand tightens on mine. Oliver stands rigid at my back with his hand on my shoulder, and I feel the shiver run through him.
I gaze at the wall.
“Safe,” I whisper.
“Katie.” Oliver’s voice is unsteady. “It’s old pipes.”
“Is it?”
He doesn’t answer.
I lean my head back against his chest. Outside, the morning has come up pale over the property. The porch lamp is still burning in the daylight, steady as a candle. On the wall by the stove, the knocks do not come again.
I don’t need them to.
Chapter 16
LUCA
I do the laundry on Wednesdays, and on Wednesdays I find out things.
It isn’t snooping. It’s housekeeping. If you hand me a pair of jeans with a hole in the knee, I’ll mend it before you’ve noticed it’s torn. If a shirt goes in with a mystery stain, I’ll know by Thursday what it was and who’s been lying about it. It’s the closest thing I have to a superpower, and I’ve never once used it for evil.
This Wednesday, I take Oliver’s work jacket off the hook by the farmhouse door and a cream-colored envelope slides out of the inside pocket and lands on the floor.
It’s heavy paper, good paper, the kind offices use. It’s addressed in a clean typed line to The Owner, Bellweather House. The flap has been opened. A corner of the letter inside is folded back, and I can see three words in blocky black type: Cash offer. Immediate.
I pick it up. I turn it over. I put it back.
I put it back exactly the way it was, flap in, corner folded, and I hang the jacket on the hook. I stand in the kitchen for a long moment with my hands wringing, looking at nothing. I’m not a stupid man. I’m only a man who has made a career of seeming like one. I have been watching Oliver for four days. I’ve watched him not meet Katie’s eyes. I’ve watched him leave rooms with a reason that wasn’t one. I watched his face change when a dead man’s name was read aloud in my back room, and I watched him say no too fast.
There’s a bylaw for most things. Bylaw nine is Henry does not have to explain. There is no bylaw for this.
So I do what I always do. I make a joke about the laundry, and I leave the jacket where it was, and I don’t say a word to anyone.
The next day, the cinnamon scent at Bellweather House is worst in the library.
I notice it first on Thursday morning, when the four of us are standing in the middle of Katie’s high-ceilinged back room, supposedly searching for the last of Evelyn’s secrets. Oliver has a tape. Henry has the flashlight. Katie has a legal pad and a pencil behind her ear, and a look in her eyes that I’ve come to recognize as I will find it or die of curiosity.
We’ve been at it for two hours. We’ve found nothing. Oliver has measured every wall, and every wall comes up exactly the length it should, and he’s started muttering at the plaster.