“Tell me something nobody knows,” she says.
“That’s a big ask.”
“You know everything about me. My radiator. My coffee. My weird house.” She tilts her head. “I don’t know anything about you except that you sold cinnamon toast at recess and you have a goat problem.”
“I don’t have a goat problem. The goat has a me problem.”
“Luca.”
I pick up a donut and turn it over. It’s easier than looking at her.
“My dad had a restaurant,” I say. “Rinaldi’s. It sat on Third Street for twenty-two years, forty seats, red checkered tablecloths, the best lasagna in three counties. Mom did the books. I was the kid who did my homework in the kitchen.” I take a bite and chew without tasting it. “It closed when I was fifteen.”
“I’m sorry.”
“It was a long time ago.” I hear the words, and I hear that I’ve said them the way Katie says it’s fine. “The last night, we had everyone in. Regulars, cousins, the guy who delivered the bread. And the whole place was so quiet. Forty people holding their forks like they were at a funeral. So I got up on a chair and did a bit.”
“A bit?”
“About the lasagna. Dad’s lasagna. I won’t repeat it. It involved a very dramatic reading of the menu.” I try to smile. “It killed. The whole room fell apart. Everybody was crying with laughter, and Dad laughed so hard he had to sit down.”
Katie doesn’t say anything. She waits.
“Then he went into the walk-in,” I say. “And I heard him crying. For about twenty minutes. And I never told anyone I heard.”
The field is very bright. A kid shrieks somewhere. Nutmeg the goat has climbed on top of a hay bale and is watching us with an air of judgment.
“That’s when I figured it out,” I tell her. “If I’m funny, nobody has to be sad in front of me. That’s the whole trick. Make the room lighter, and nobody asks what you’re carrying.” I turn the donut again. “I’ve been funny for twenty years. I’m very good at it. The problem is that when you’re the funny one, nobody checks whether there’s anything else in there.”
“Is that what happens with Oliver and Henry?”
“They love me. I know they do.” I make myself say the rest. “When Oliver and I bought the farmhouse, he asked me what color to paint the kitchen. That’s it. A whole big decision, mortgage and roof and septic, and I got to pick yellow.”
“Is that a joke?”
“It’s the most honest thing I’ve said in a decade.”
I look up.
Katie isn’t smiling. Her eyes are very clear and very dark, and the whole of her face has gone soft in a way that I’d give a year of my life to deserve. She reaches across the table and puts her hand over mine, over the donut, over all of it.
“I don’t think you’re just the fun one,” she says.
“Katie…”
“I think you’re the one who holds everything. I think you’ve noticed so much, for so long, that the only way to carry it all is to make it look like fun.” Her thumb moves across my knuckles. “You noticed my radiator story. You noticed I was tired this morning and didn’t make me say it. You noticed the second I got in the van that I was wearing Henry’s coat, and you made a joke so I wouldn’t have to feel bad about it.”
I can’t speak. It’s the first time in my adult life that I have nothing on the shelf. Not a quip, not a deflection, not a single bright, useful lie.
“I see you,” Katie says. “Okay? I just want you to know. I see you.”
A long, slow breath goes out of me, and with it something I’ve been holding since I was fifteen years old and standing on a chair in a quiet room.
“Okay,” I say, and my voice breaks in the middle, and I let it.
We finish our terrible coffees and wonderful donuts.
The antique shop is her idea.