“Yes.”
“She wasn’t leaving. She was carrying her. The whole time.”
“Yes.”
“I thought it was a grave.”
“It’s a cradle,” I say.
She turns her head, and looks at me with wet, shining eyes. Then she lets out a short, peaceful breath, and turns her face into my shoulder.
It’s a long time before any of us moves.
At one o’clock, Katie sits down at the kitchen table.
She has washed her face. She has put on dry clothes. June has gone home, escorted by Luca with a lantern, over the objections of both. The dishes are done. The house is quiet, golden, ordinary, and warm, and Katie has the stack of cream envelopes in front of her, tied with twine.
Oliver is standing by the sink. He hasn’t been told to leave. He hasn’t been told to stay. He stands with his arms resting naturally at his sides and waits.
Katie takes a black marker out of the drawer.
She unties the twine. She spreads the six envelopes out in a row on the wood, and she writes across each one, in thick, square letters, with the cap clenched between her teeth.
NOT FOR SALE. EVER.
She caps the pen. She looks at the row.
“I’m not burning them,” she says. “I thought about it. I’d like to. But I want Mr. Pell to read them. I want him to tell me how many other letters like these have come to this house in fifty years, and where they went.” She stacks them, squares the edges, and ties the twine. “And I want a lawyer. Someone who will make sure a Monroe never steps foot on this property ever again.”
“Yes,” Oliver says.
“And I’m keeping the house.”
“Yes.”
“I don’t need you to say yes to that.”
“It’s the only answer I’ve got.” His mouth is rough. “I’m sorry.”
“I know.” She sets the stack at the center of the table. She looks at him, and I watch it cross her face, the anger, the grief, the huge, unwilling tenderness. She doesn’t say I forgive you. She doesn’t say I don’t. She says, “You gave them back.”
“It was the least I could do.”
“It was the right thing.” Her voice cracks. “It was late. But it was right. That counts.”
Oliver closes his eyes.
She gets up. She goes to the window over the sink, where the first haze of morning is just coming over the garden wall, the tree in its pool of fading dark, the lamp in the porch still burning at the front of the house. She stands with her arms wrapped around herself. After a moment, I get up and go to her. I don’t touch her. I stand beside her, a foot away, in the quiet.
“It wasn’t calling me to find a body,” she says softly.
“No.”
“It was calling me home.”
“Yes.”
She turns her head. In the dull light, she looks very young, and very tired, and entirely herself. “Thank you for staying,” Katie says.