CHAPTER ONE
CHARLOTTE
The October air smells like fried dough and wood smoke, and I pull my cardigan tighter as I weave through the crowd on the village green. Strings of orange lights crisscross between the craft stalls, and somewhere near the bandstand, a fiddle is tuning up. I stop at the pie contest table first because that feels like the right order of operations, and let’s be real. Who can refuse homemade pie?
I’m standing there, wrestling with indecision. Do I go for just a single, decadent slice of pecan pie, or hell, do I splurge and buy the whole damn pie? The decadent smell of caramelized pecans taunts me, sugary-sweet and impossible to ignore. Then, out of nowhere, a voice rings out, slicing through my sweet-tooth haze. “You must be the new librarian.”
I turn, startled, and lock eyes with a woman in her fifties, maybe older. She’s got the posture of someone who runs the show and doesn’t have time for bullshit, her hand shooting out for a shake. “I’m Millie Rusk. I own the Gull’s Nest Diner.” Her steely grip is unyielding. Her gray hair is yanked back into a severe bun, not a decorative pin in sight, just a few wild curls escaping to brush her cheekbones. Navy skirt, sensible shoes, a cream cable-knit sweater hugging her sturdy shoulders. Her posture is rigid with authority, her grip unyielding as a handshake, but her blue eyes hold a warmth that suggests she would help you out of a jam just as quickly as she’d point out your mistake.
She sizes me up, taking in the way I hover next to the dessert table, frozen by my pie dilemma, and there’s a hint of a smile tugging at her mouth, a little amused, a whole lot welcoming.
“Nice to finally meet you.” I look around the crowded fairgrounds. “The turnout is crazy.”
“We always have a good showing at the Smitten Harbor Fall Festival.” She says it like a fact, not a brag, and then she’s beside me, looping her free arm through mine. “I can see you have the usual look of someone new to our town.”
“What look?”
“The one that says you’re trying to decide if this town is a Hallmark movie or a true-crime documentary.” She squeezes my arm. “Relax, honey. You’ll get used to it.”
I laugh and glance around at the clusters of people nearby. A woman in a quilted vest is watching us over her cup of cider. Two men by the hay bales are definitely looking in our direction. I’m still new enough that I register as a curiosity, and I haven’t decided yet whether that’s charming or claustrophobic.
“I seem to be the most interesting thing here.”
Millie laughs, the sound carrying over the chaos of the pie table and landing hard. “It won’t take long for you to become old news. Before long, they’ll go back to arguing about who cheated at the cornhole tournament last year, or who ruined the landscaping at the post office.” She takes her slice of pecan pie and practically shoves a fork into my hand. “Eat so you have the energy to give the locals something to talk about.”
I accept the pie from her and take a bite. I hate standing out. Or maybe I just hate feeling like I don’t belong. I traded subway noise and city lights for wood smoke, porch lights, and a boring existence. I’m still not sure if it’s brave or just freaking stupid. But I want it. More than anything, I want to belong somewhere.
“Just in case you haven’t figured it out yet, gossip is the town sport.” Millie watches me inhale the pie.
“I realized that about thirty seconds after I walked into the library the first day.”
“You’re perceptive.” She winks and heads back around the back of the pie table. “Don’t worry, doll. You’ll fit in just fine around here.”
God, I hope so. I mutter under my breath as I make my way to the cider stand, where a teenager in a Smitten Harbor Fire Department hoodie pours me a cup and hands it over. I wrap both hands around the paper cup and let the heat seep into my fingers. The steam curls up into my face, and for a second, I close my eyes and just breathe it in—cinnamon, apple, and the faint bite of something fermented underneath. Contentment flows through my soul. This is what I wanted when I took the library job. Small moments that feel like they belong to me.
I open my eyes and turn to find a spot near the craft stalls, and that’s when I walk directly into a freaking brick wall. Or more accurately, a huge freaking human wall.
The cider sloshes. I feel it happen in slow motion, the cup tipping, the liquid arcing, the splash hitting something solid. I stumble back, and my first clear thought is that I’ve just dumped hot cider all over a pair of very polished boots.
“Damn.” The word comes out before I can stop it, and I look up.
He’s broad-shouldered and tall enough that I have to tilt my head back. Close-cropped dark hair, a jaw that looks like it was carved from something unforgiving, and eyes that are already fixed on me with an expression I can’t quite read. The starched uniform and spotless boots say he cares about keeping things in order.
“Are you hurt?” His voice is clipped, steady. No anger, just assessment.
“I’m fine. Your boots, though.” I gesture at the mess with my empty cup. “I’m so sorry. I wasn’t looking where I was…”
“It’s no big deal.” He glances down at his boots, then back at me. “It’ll wash off.”
I wait for the part where he tells me to be more careful, or where he makes a joke about clumsy newcomers, but he doesn’t. He just stands there, watching me with an intensity that makes my fingers tighten on the crumpled cup.
“I’m Noah Stafford.” I watch his full lips moving, wondering if I’ve suddenly stepped into the Twilight Zone. “The town sheriff.” Now I wonder what they would feel like pressed against mine.
I blink several times and pull myself together. “Charlotte Beaumont, the new librarian,” I swallow hard and glance down at his stained boots, “slash public nuisance.”
One corner of his mouth moves, not quite a smile, but close. “Nice to run into you.”
I laugh before I can stop myself, and his expression shifts. Something flickers behind his eyes that makes my stomach do a slow, unwelcome flip. I’m not here for this. I’m here for a quiet, fresh start and a library that needs organizing, and maybe, eventually, a sense that I belong somewhere. I am not here to get flustered over a stern-faced sheriff with boots that probably cost more than my monthly grocery budget.