Father Brian studied the words, a slow smile creeping onto his lips. ‘In Paradise Lost, Milton presents disobedience as the inevitable consequence of unequal authority.’ He lowered the paper and looked pridefully at his son. ‘This really is exemplary. No wonder Doctor Van Hasselt has suggested your future might lie in the written word.’
Eliza leaned back in her chair. ‘I agree, Papa. Bramwell has a real flair for writing.’ She looked at her brother, a smirk now visible on her face. ‘He was just telling me how much he adores English Literature. Particularly the work of Milton.’
‘Indeed. Speaking of which, you’d better run along, Bram. We can’t have you being late for your next lesson.’
‘Of course not, Papa.’ Father Brian returned his essay. ‘I will see you this evening for dinner after prep. Goodbye, Eliza.’
‘Goodbye, Bram. Enjoy Latin.’ She gave him a surreptitious wink as he skulked out of the door.
‘Right then,’ said Father Brian, bringing his hands together. ‘You’re due to accompany me to the bedside of Doctor Dobson’s wife. I have been informed that her condition is worsening and that she doesn’t have long left.’
Eliza groaned. ‘The lady with the wasting disease?’ Her father nodded. ‘Oh, Papa, she doesn’t want me there. She wants to talk to you about God and repentance and Heaven.’
Her father gave her a steely look. ‘And why does that preclude your presence?’
‘Because I’m a spare part. Unnecessary.’
‘The older members of my flock appreciate your presence, Eliza. You’re …’ – he paused, searching for the right words – ‘demure and calming.’
‘And silent,’ Eliza added. ‘To be seen and not heard.’
‘Who says that the silent are not appreciated?’
Eliza stood, knowing that this was not a fight she could win. ‘No one. But the silent do not make a difference.’
Her father walked over to her and placed a hand on her shoulder. ‘I know that your mind is busy, Eliza. I suspect even busier than mine.’ His voice was steady and low. ‘But the world outside these walls values order and measure. You must learn that one cannot act upon every thought as though it were decree.’ He paused, his eyes fixed on hers.
Eliza fought the urge to scoff. Her father was not a bad man by any stretch of the imagination. She just wished desperately that he understood her better. ‘I think it’s the school, Papa. I probably wouldn’t feel it as much if the Church had stationed you in some tiny village in the middle of nowhere.’
‘We are incredibly lucky to be here at Harrow. The opportunities it has given …’ Father Brian checked himself.
‘… Bram,’ interjected Eliza, ‘are incredible!’
‘You have a lovely home in a beautiful part of England. You are surrounded by individuals who will go on to play pivotal roles in the leadership of this country, and you would do well to remember that.’
‘I do remember that,’ Eliza replied honestly. ‘That’s the problem! Bram gets to go out every day and … and … learn! And I’m stuck in here polishing tables with Mama!’
‘Society is a structure built over generations, sustained by manners and careful thought,’ he retorted.
‘You would say that, Papa.’
‘And why is that?’
‘Because you’re on the right side of it.’ Father Brian raised an eyebrow. ‘You’re a man.’
Her father folded his arms. ‘You may think that wit can excuse mischief, but it does not. Your duty, as a member of this family and as a woman of station, is to navigate life with prudence. That is the path that protects you from needless suffering. Now.’ He brought his hands together once more. ‘Let us go and give Mrs Dobson counsel.’
Being a beak had many associated privileges, the most obvious of which was that your house was provided by the school. The Dobsons’ residence stood just beyond the main school buildings. Inside, polished wooden floors reflected the warm glow of oil lamps as Doctor Dobson led Eliza and her father upstairs to the bedroom.
The room was small and the air heavy with the lingering warmth of the day’s fire. The bed, draped in a quilted blanket, rose slightly at the head where Mrs Dobson lay, pale and fragile beneath a neatly folded shawl. Her breathing was quiet and measured, as though each inhalation required effort.
‘I’ll leave you with her,’ said Doctor Dobson, hurrying back down the corridor as if he had become fearful of the room and what it contained.
‘Good afternoon, Mrs Dobson. It’s Father Brian and Eliza to see you.’
She gave an almost imperceptible nod. ‘Hello, Father.’
‘May we have a seat?’ Another slight movement of the head. ‘Thank you.’