“I told her there were still possibilities. People she could contact. She wasn’t too old.”
“And on Monday she told you to stop.”
“She told me she was happy.”
The contempt in the last word was stronger than anything Margaret had said about Claire’s work. Selena let a few seconds pass.
“Was that when you decided to kill her?”
Margaret stared through the windshield. “I’d spent years thinking they might change their minds. That they needed someone to remind them.” Her jaw tightened. “Claire’s message made it clear. She wasn’t waiting for her life to improve. She thought that was her life.”
“It was.”
“She thanked me as though I were someone selling something at her door.”
Selena remembered the short, restrained reply. I appreciate what you did for me.
“On Monday,” she said, “you decided asking wasn’t enough.”
“I decided I was finished asking.”
The Subaru passed a dark house with a porch light burning. Selena wanted Margaret to pull in, to encounter another person, to do anything that would break the isolation. The light disappeared behind them.
“And after Claire?”
Margaret adjusted the mirror by a fraction. “Iris and Paulette had already made their choices. I didn’t need another message.”
Selena held on to that answer. Years of collecting and resentment, then a specific refusal. Margaret had taken Claire’s decision as a verdict on the life she had spent directing other people.
“Iris had no reason to go to Milligan’s,” she said. “What did you tell her?”
“That we needed advice about a benefit performance. Something to help children whose parents couldn’t afford lessons.”
“When did you ask her?”
“Wednesday. Outside her office.”
“You told me you hadn’t spoken to her since the spring.”
“You believed me.”
Selena ignored the satisfaction in Margaret’s voice. “There was no booking at the hall.”
“There didn’t need to be. I told her I’d arranged access after the evening activities. She only had to come and look at the stage.”
That explained the car and the absence of an electronic invitation. A brief conversation with someone Iris knew, an ordinary favor she hadn’t thought to discuss with her brother.
“How did you get in?”
Margaret hesitated, then said, “I still had a key.”
“From the school performances?”
“Yes.”
“You said you’d returned them.”
“One of them.”