“Ms. Yole, it’s Sheriff Chase. I need to speak with you.”
No lights came on. He pressed the doorbell and heard a faint chime inside, but nothing followed it.
From the doorway, he could see part of the sitting room through a gap between the curtains at the nearest front window. A small table stood close to the glass, with a chair angled beside it.
Something red hung over the chair’s back.
Connor stopped with his hand still near the bell.
He turned on his flashlight and directed it through the gap. A narrow length of glossy material draped over the wood, one end hanging almost to the floor. The color brought him back to Milligan’s and the red satin arranged around Iris’s body.
He kept his feet on the porch and shifted the beam.
Ribbon wasn’t proof of anything. Neither was an empty driveway after midnight. But he had come here to question a woman whose car tires were consistent with impressions at another murder scene, and whose connection to the victims had grown more troubling with each set of records.
Connor took out his phone and photographed what he could see.
Below the ribbon, the edge of an open scrapbook rested on the table. Several loose pages lay beside it. His flashlight caught a photograph of a young woman standing next to a painting.
He knew her before he found the name beneath it.
Claire Duvall.
Connor brought the phone closer to the glass without touching it and zoomed in on the screen. The photograph was old. Claire’s hair was different, and she had the unguarded smile of someone pleased to have her work noticed.
He had seen that painting in one of the articles in the case file.
Another clipping lay partly across the facing page. Only the top was visible, but it showed a dancer in costume beneath a headline mentioning Iris Leary.
Connor held the phone steady.
Margaret had spent decades working with students. She had photographs of them throughout the house. A scrapbook could be exactly what it seemed: a retired counselor’s record of people she had helped.
The ribbon lay within reach of the book.
He checked his phone for Selena’s reply before calling dispatch.
“Chase. I’m on the front porch at Yole’s address. No answer at the door. Through the front window, I can see red material resembling the satin used at Milligan’s, alongside clippings about Claire Duvall and Iris Leary.”
The dispatcher acknowledged him.
“Have the on-call prosecutor contact me. We need to discuss a search warrant for the residence. Send another deputy here to watch the property. Arnold’s checking Agent Raven at the motel.”
“Understood. Do you need anyone else?”
“Not at the house yet. Let me know who’s coming.”
Connor ended the transmission. He could break the door and have every room checked in minutes, but nothing he had seen put Selena inside. Her SUV wasn’t here. No one had cried for help, moved, or left a sign of a struggle.
He wasn’t going to turn fear into an excuse to search.
Instead, he made a short recording of the view from the doorway, showing the curtain gap, the table and the chair. He spoke his location and the time for the record, then stopped the recording and sent the images to the department.
His phone rang almost immediately.
He answered without checking the screen. “Selena?”
“It’s Arnold.”