CHAPTER 6
Losing You
Sylvia
He calls on a Thursday afternoon.
I recognize him even before I see the screen. It's a deep, instinctive certainty, similar to how I used to sense, when he was little, whether footsteps belonged to him or if silence signaled danger. Some acknowledgments linger physically longer than they do in reason. My hand moves instinctively before my mind registers the recognition. By the time I see his name, my heart races so intensely that it feels more like harm than emotion.
I have been waiting for this call for three months.
I haven't admitted it openly or honestly. I've graded papers, made coffee, answered emails, walked along the shoreline, and told myself I wasn't waiting. I've acted like a reasonable woman with a husband, a house, a pile of student essays, and enough experience to understand that hope can be humiliating if it rises too quickly. But my body recognizes what my pride has been avoiding. It understands the form of waiting. It recognizes the sound of his name lighting up the screen.
I pick up before the second ring.
“Mom.”
Only a single word. Yet, it strikes me physically; my throat contracts around it. My hand grows cold as it grips the phone. In that reckless moment, I forget I am fifty-five years old, sitting at my kitchen table with legal papers nearby and a cease-and-desist letter dispatched. For an instant, I become all the versions of his mother I have ever been: the woman lifting him from his crib, the one answering a college call at two in the morning, the mother who hears his voice and, before proof is in, believes love remains the absolute truth.
I have rehearsed this moment in the dark more times than I could count if I wanted to. I have imagined tears, anger, explanation, apology, some breach in him wide enough for truth to get through.
Nothing prepared me for the ordinariness of his voice.
That is the cruelest part. He sounds like himself. Not transformed, not fevered, not unreachable. Just Connor. Just my son, in the same voice he used to ask whether a melon was ripe, or tell me he had aced a defense, or call from a parking lot because he had suddenly noticed something ordinary and wanted me to notice it too.
“Connor,” I say.
I want to ask, “Where have you been?” I want to ask, “Do you know what these months have cost us?” I want to ask, “Did you know about the police report, the threats, the words she sent us, and the things she has called me?” I want to say, “I have loved you every day of your life, and I do not know what story you are living in if I am the villain in it.”
Instead, I say only his name, because there are moments in life when saying less is the only way not to lose everything at once.
He tells me the cease-and-desist letter arrived.
He says it evenly, the way a person states weather, traffic, or some other neutral fact of the world. There is no opening in the sentence. No son in it, no personal touch, nothing that reminds me of my child. There is only a man delivering prepared information. I can hear, as plainly as if paper were rustling beside his mouth, that he has thought about this call in advance. He has practiced the line and is staying close to the script.
“I know,” I say. “Patricia Keene sent it.”
What I don’t say is I know they’ve had the letter for at least two weeks now. Patricia sent it certified the same week Walt visited her office. But Connor waited before calling me.
There is the smallest pause.
He didn't know her name, but I heard him realize it. I sensed him understanding, in a limited and still incomplete way, that things have changed more than he thought. It’s not enough, yet it’s something. During these months, I’ve become a woman who spots crumbs and considers them nourishment, because what else is there to do?
“Claudia was upset,” he says.
I say nothing.
The room is so silent that I can hear the refrigerator turn on. My pen rests on a student essay about The Great Gatsby, which I have been grading for twenty minutes. Suddenly, the green light in the novel feels less like symbolism and more like a diagnosis—a tragic pursuit of connection across water, driven by the belief that sincere desire can bridge the gap between dreams and reality.
“She said—” He stops. Begins again. “She said she never wanted this to go so far. She said she never wanted to lose you. Either of you.”
The sentence settles into the room like poison in clear water.
I am sitting at the kitchen table. The lake is outside the window. The student papers are spread in front of me. The legal file is three rooms away in the study drawer. The police report exists. The screenshots exist. The messages she sent to Walt exist. The messages she sent to me exist. The words online exist. The town exists. My marriage exists. My son’s voice exists. Everything is here at once, and now this sentence is here too.
She never wanted to lose you.
This is what the moment requires of me: I must hold the sentence and the police report in the same hand. I must hold that sentence and the legal threat, and the social media posts, and the words narcissistic and breaking the cycle, and the messages sent from her own phone to ours, and my own son calmly offering me her feelings as though they were the central fact of the situation. I must hold all of it at once and keep my voice from breaking open around it.