“Yes, it’s possible.”
“So, she can be happy? Even if it doesn’t start out that way?”
Liam nodded.
“Then why does she have to leave if she finds her pelt? Why can’t she stay?”
“Because all selkies yearn to get back to the sea.”
“Even the ones who are in love with their husbands? And have children together?”
“Yes,” Liam said.
“But…how can they just abandon their families like that?”
“It’s not an entirely selfish decision.”
“Isn’t it?” Grace asked.
“No,” Liam said. “Remember, they were never supposed to be here in the first place. This isn’t their home.”
“But doesn’t it become their home after a while? Isn’t a home more about being with the people you love?”
They reached the westernmost tip of the island, and the ocean stretched out before them, as far as the eye could see. “I think for some people that’s true,” Liam said. “But for others the concept of home is inextricably linked to a sense of place. It’s a connection with the environment, the culture, and the history of a place, as much as the people we share it with. There are some places that speak to us, that get in our blood, that grab hold of us and never let go. These places become a part of us. And we lose a part of ourselves if we’re separated from them for too long.”
Grace thought about Heron Island and all the things she loved about it in addition to the people who lived there. Liam had a point. She did feel like a part of herself was missing whenever she was away from it for too long.
But she had also never been in love. What if she met someone, someday, and he wanted to live somewhere else?
Would she be able to give up her home for a man she loved?
As they continued north around the loop, they passed an occasional herd of sheep. Other than that, there was nothing but the two of them, the cliffs, and the open sea. “What would happen,” Grace asked a few minutes later when their path curved inland and they could hear each other over the wind again, “if a selkie chose not to return to the sea?”
Liam’s eyes cut to hers. “What do you mean?”
“Well,” Grace said slowly, “you’ve studied these legends extensively for years. Have you ever come across a story where a selkie chose to stay?”
Liam looked away, and for the first time since they’d started to walk, he didn’t seem quite so at ease with himself. “I…” He trailed off and appeared to be choosing his words carefully. “I can’t say I’ve ever come across one that was written down.”
That wasn’t an answer, Grace thought. Most legends were passed down orally for generations before they ever got written down. And surely, he hadn’t captured all the ones he’d heard in writing yet. “So, let me get this straight,” she said, opting to play along rather than call him out, “no matter how happy a selkie is with her family, she will never choose to stay on land if she finds her pelt?”
Liam nodded. “That’s the general rule, yes.”
“But…?”
He took a breath. “But as a researcher, I tend to avoid using absolutes.”
“So, it is possible?”
“I think,” he said, looking back at her, “that anything is possible.”
“Okay,” Grace said, “let’s assume, just for fun, that there was an exception to the rule. What would happen if a selkie chose to stay?”
That, Liam thought, was a question he didn’t know the answer to. And it was one that had been troubling him a lot lately. Because the only exception to that rule, at least that he knew of, was his mother.
And he didn’t know the ending to her story yet.
It had been almost seven years since his mother had made the decision to stay, to relinquish her crown as the selkie queen and remain on land with her family. For much of that time, everything had been fine. Recently, though, things had begun to change.